Abstract:There is currently much interest in conducting spatial analyses of health outcomes at the small-area scale. This requires sophisticated statistical techniques, usually involving Bayesian models, to smooth the underlying risk estimates because the data are typically sparse. However, questions have been raised about the performance of these models for recovering the "true" risk surface, about the influence of the prior structure specified, and about the amount of smoothing of the risks that is actually performed. We describe a comprehensive simulation study designed to address these questions. Our results show that Bayesian disease-mapping models are essentially conservative, with high specificity even in situations with very sparse data but low sensitivity if the raised-risk areas have only a moderate (less than 2-fold) excess or are not based on substantial expected counts (> 50 per area). Semiparametric spatial mixture models typically produce less smoothing than their conditional autoregressive counterpart when there is sufficient information in the data (moderate-size expected count and/or high true excess risk). Sensitivity may be improved by exploiting the whole posterior distribution to try to detect true raised-risk areas rather than just reporting and mapping the mean posterior relative risk. For the widely used conditional autoregressive model, we show that a decision rule based on computing the probability that the relative risk is above 1 with a cutoff between 70 and 80% gives a specific rule with reasonable sensitivity for a range of scenarios having moderate expected counts (approximately 20) and excess risks (approximately 1.5- to 2-fold). Larger (3-fold) excess risks are detected almost certainly using this rule, even when based on small expected counts, although the mean of the posterior distribution is typically smoothed to about half the true value.

A Study on the Method for Determining Statistical Risk Boundaries for Spatial Data with Application to Traffic Accident Data

Application of Poisson random effect models for highway network screening

Spatial regression analysis of traffic crashes in Seoul

Division and Analysis of Accident-Prone Areas near Highway Ramps Based on Spatial Autocorrelation

Likelihood-based Estimation of Spatial Intensity and Variation in Disease Risk from Locations Observed with Error

Evaluation of the Impact of Spatial and Environmental Accident Factors on Severity Patterns of Road Segments

Applications of Generalized Additive and Bayesian Hierarchical Models for Areal Safety Analysis: Case Study of an Urban Multimodal Transportation System in Chicago, Illinois

Analyzing the Relationship Between User Feedback and Traffic Accidents Through Crowdsourced Data

Analysis of Spatiotemporal Factors Affecting Traffic Safety Based on Multisource Data Fusion

Bayesian space-time modeling of bicycle and pedestrian crash risk by injury severity levels to explore the long-term spatiotemporal effects

Negative Binomial Regression Model for Disaggregate Analysis of Road Accidents in Hong Kong

Determining the road traffic accident hotspots using GIS-based temporal-spatial statistical analytic techniques in Hanoi, Vietnam

Investigating Spatial Autocorrelation and Spillover Effects in Freeway Crash-Frequency Data

Macrolevel Traffic Crash Analysis: A Spatial Econometric Model Approach

A spatial econometrics perspective on the characteristics of urban traffic accidents: focusing on elderly drivers' accidents in Seoul, South Korea

Modeling conflict risk with real-time traffic data for road safety assessment: a copula-based joint approach

Is Traffic Congestion Bad for Road Traffic Accidents? Spatiotemporal Analysis of United Kingdom Major Roads Using Spatial Econometrics

Spatial Regression Analysis of Pedestrian Crashes Based on Point-of-Interest Data

Interpreting posterior relative risk estimates in disease-mapping studies

ANALYSIS OF ASSOCIATION BETWEEN TRAFFIC EXPOSURE AND ACCIDENT RISK IN HONG KONG

Network space analysis–based identification of road traffic accident hotspots: a case study