Reflections on the Algebra I Classroom Introduction

Alyssa MacMahon,Davidson Barr

DOI: https://doi.org/10.52214/jmetc.v13i1.9722

2022-05-25

Journal of Mathematics Education at Teachers College

Abstract:Notes from the Field Introduction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Untangling Classroom Positionings: An Instrumental Case Unpacking Positioning Theory in Mathematics Education

Daniel Edelen,Sarah B. Bush,Ashley Schmidt,Tandrea Fulton,Lybrya Kebreab,Treshonda Rutledge

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19477503.2022.2038470

2022-02-25

Investigations in Mathematics Learning

Abstract:In this paper, we aim to untangle positioning theory (Davies & Harré, 1990) and its implications for the field of mathematics education research, considering both existing use and potential use. Specific theoretical assumptions of positions or positionings in the context of learning mathematics are outlined. In this paper, a classroom-based instrumental case study illuminates examples of how students are positioned within their mathematical experiences as a means to understand some of the factors that affect how students come to exist within mathematical spaces and how classroom-based positionings impact students’ opportunities to engage in learning. Our goal is to present positioning theory as a potential tool for how our teaching practices impact students’ experiences in mathematical spaces. We present a moment-by-moment analysis, from an ethnographic perspective of the case, to clearly demonstrate how positioning theory may be utilized for both research and practice within mathematics education research. Implications for methodology and positioning theory through an ethnographic perspective are shared.
The Nature and Quality of Algebra Instruction: Using a Content-Focused Observation Tool as a Lens for Understanding and Improving Instructional Practice

Erica Litke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07370008.2019.1616740

2019-06-13

Cognition and Instruction

Abstract:Algebra is a key course in the high school mathematics sequence. Despite its prominence, large-scale examinations of algebra instruction are rare and it is not clear whether and how instructional practices that support students' learning of algebra content manifest in classroom instruction. Drawing on video from 108 ninth-grade algebra lessons from 5 districts recorded as part of the Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) Project, I describe instruction using scores from a newly developed, algebra-focused observation tool to ground the description of instructional practice in the content being taught. I present the range of instructional formats and the nature and quality of algebra-focused instructional features related to the teaching of procedures and to the ways in which teachers leverage connections to support students' algebra learning. To illustrate these descriptive results, I present case studies of 2 lessons: 1 rated typical and 1 rated high-quality. I find that although the majority of lessons in the sample follow traditional formats, specific instructional features that benefit student learning in algebra are present to a modest degree across lessons, though not often at high levels of quality. The case lessons demonstrate both glimmers of promise and missed opportunities to engage in instruction that benefits student learning of algebra. I discuss the implications of these results for improving the quality of algebra teaching and argue for the affordances of a content-focused observation tool as a lens for instructional improvement efforts.

psychology, experimental, educational
Restructuring for Mathematical Power: Techniques for Teaching Thinking in Algebra

Barbara Nelson

Abstract:RESTRUCTURING FOR MATHEMATICAL POWER: TECHNIQUES FOR TEACHING THINKING IN ALGEBRA DECEMBER, 1992 BARBARA D. NELSON, B.A., CORNELL UNIVERSITY M.A., UNIVERSITY OF MASSACHUSETTS AT BOSTON Directed by: Professor Patricia S. Davidson Recent critiques of mathematics education have resulted in proposals to restructure learning and teaching for mathematical power. The new vision pictures the classroom as a community of learners where mathematics comes alive as a useful tool in our technological society. However, many high school mathematics teachers are struggling to understand and implement the fundamental instructional change inherent in the vision. Written from the perspective of a high school teacher for experienced high school mathematics teachers, this thesis attempts to bridge vision and practice. To clarify the vision, current literature on reform in mathematics education is synthesized into a framework of eight instructional targets. Four of the targets focus on student behavior indicative of mathematical power: deep understanding of concepts and schemas, mathematical thinking, communication about mathematics and a positive disposition toward mathematics. The other four targets focus on the instructional setting: student-centered tasks,

Computer Science,Education,Mathematics
“Our Voyage with Knowing and Teaching Elementary Mathematics”

Taajah Felder Witherspoon,Macie G. Halvorson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5951/mtlt.2024.0104

2024-10-01

Abstract:From the Archives highlights articles from NCTM’s legacy journals, previously discussed during MTLT Teacher Talk.
Teaching Writing and Communication in a Mathematical Modeling Course

Jean Marie Linhart

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10511970.2014.895459

2014-06-18

PRIMUS

Abstract:Writing and communication are essential skills for success in the workplace or in graduate school, yet writing and communication are often the last thing that instructors think about incorporating into a mathematics course. A mathematical modeling course provides a natural environment for writing assignments. This article is an analysis of the type of writing assigned in my mathematical modeling course. Where the assignments are unusual, they are thoroughly described and I share my experiences on what worked well and what was not as successful. Where the assignments are more traditional, I offer an analysis of problems and pitfalls in teaching writing. Formal project reports for the class teach students how to write scientific articles. Unusual reflective assignments help students integrate their learning and apply it in new contexts.
Including School Mathematics Teaching Applications in an Undergraduate Abstract Algebra Course

James A. M. Álvarez,Andrew Kercher,Kyle Turner,Elizabeth G. Arnold,Elizabeth A. Burroughs,Elizabeth W. Fulton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10511970.2021.1912230

2021-05-04

PRIMUS

Abstract:We describe the design and implementation of lessons in undergraduate abstract algebra that integrate applications to teaching high school mathematics. Each lesson consists of a pre-activity, class activity, homework set, assessment questions and detailed instructor notes. The included applications intend to bridge advanced mathematics concepts to secondary school mathematics content for prospective secondary mathematics teachers, as well as provide instructors with a useful resource. Each lesson includes four guiding features: addressing meaningful content; making connections to mathematics teaching; emphasizing active learning; and providing comprehensive notes for instructors. Interviews with instructors and their students document how the instructors adapted the lessons to their classrooms and how the lessons influenced undergraduates' mathematical understanding.
Math Confidence in an Elementary Mathematics Classroom

Tara Palmer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.62798/lvwc6537

2020-12-12

Abstract:I am a fourth- and fifth-grade teacher at a K–12 developmental research school in which I conducted action research examining how instruction impacted student confidence during a mathematics block. I conducted anonymous surveys and student interviews and studied how instructional strategies used for math support positively affect student math confidence and selfperception. The students offered insights into their experiences and suggestions for future implementation. This work developed a unique homework set-up to personalize and support students at their level while targeting specific skills. I will continue to work to increase student self-efficacy.
What Group Theory Can Do for You: From Magmas to Abstract Thinking in School Mathematics

Joaquin Marc Veith,Philipp Bitzenbauer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/math10050703

IF: 2.4

2022-02-23

Mathematics

Abstract:In this paper, we present a novel concept for an abstract algebra course at the secondary school level. Against the backdrop of findings from mathematics education research, we discuss benefits that arise from teaching abstract algebra to secondary school students. We derive suitable content items as well as educational ideas on how to implement them into mathematics classrooms. We build on frameworks from mathematics education research to design a teaching-learning sequence that enables a beneficial learning trajectory across three units—the result is a coherent teaching concept that encompasses Magmas in a hands-on way. It can be used for either extra-curricular activities or advanced courses in mathematics classes, and can be of benefit for mathematics learners.

mathematics
Reflective journaling in mathematics: Insights into the development of future teachers

Jill Zarestky,Michelle Bigler

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/nha3.20334

2021-06-01

New Horizons in Adult Education and Human Resource Development

Abstract:Given their responsibilities and influence on future students, preservice mathematics teachers’ preparation is critically important. This research's purpose was to explore reflective journaling for preservice teachers in advanced undergraduate mathematics courses. To accomplish this purpose, 39 preservice teachers enrolled in upper–level undergraduate mathematics courses shared evidence from their semester–long learning journals including self–perceptions as learners and future professionals. Student journals were analyzed using qualitative thematic methods; themes included perseverance through challenge, self–awareness of learning behaviors, building content knowledge, and future teaching connections. Participants perceived themselves as mathematics learners experiencing challenges and successes and as future educators building skills and preparing for the workplace. Findings reveal journaling's particular usefulness for building the mathematical habits of mind and professional mentality of preservice teachers, helping them to begin the transition of their viewpoints from student to teacher. This study has implications for preparing future teachers and designing corresponding undergraduate mathematics courses.
REFLECTIONS ON TASK-BASED LANGUAGE TEACHING

Elham Mohammadi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21153/tesol2020vol29no2art1429

2020-12-31

TESOL in Context

Abstract:REFLECTIONS ON TASK-BASED LANGUAGE TEACHING Rod EllisBristol, Blue Ridge Summit: Multilingual Matters, 2018
When Traditional Won't Do: Experiences from a “Lower-Level” Mathematics Classroom

Crystal Hill

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00098655.2010.484439

2010-09-24

The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas

Abstract:As the last bell rings, students scurry to their respective classrooms, doors begin to close, and the class period begins. Imagine that you are in the hallway of the school and you look into an advanced mathematics class, into an Algebra I, Part I, mathematics class (a course designed for students who have not found success in mathematics). What would you see? What type of instructional strategies and learning activities would you expect to take place in each of these classrooms? Research suggests that the activities in most “lower-level” mathematics classes require simple memory and comprehension skills, whereas classroom activities in so-called advanced classes are more likely to foster critical thinking, problem solving, and the ability to generalize (Hill 2008, 39).
Using Student Reflections to Develop Deep Teaching

Jordan Kostiuk

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10511970.2024.2303648

2024-01-26

PRIMUS

Abstract:National studies continue to indicate that the graduating STEM student body is not representative of the diversity of the U.S. population. In addition to, or in the absence of, institutional change, instructors must learn how to implement equity-focused pedagogical changes in order to better support their students. This article describes my experience introducing a weekly reflection protocol in a proof-based mathematics course with the dual goals of promoting metacognition and opening an additional communication channel with my students. Towards these goals, this intervention was largely successful and I provide examples of how I was able to use what I learned from my students to better support them throughout the semester. Drawing on the "Deep Teaching Model" for faculty development, I share how this experience continues to be a critical component of my evolving teaching practice. Though this intervention on its own may not solve the representation and equity problems in our field, the self-awareness I developed through this experience has positioned me as a more effective instructor, mentor, and advocate.
Describing and Interpreting the Space of Classroom Learning in Problem-Solving-Based Mathematics Instruction: Variation as an Analytical Lens

Berie Getie Kassa,Liping Ding,Alemayehu Bishaw Tamiru

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci13020111

2023-01-21

Education Sciences

Abstract:The field of mathematics education research has been promoting problem-solving-based mathematics instruction (PS-based MI) to afford opportunities to develop students' conceptual understanding and problem-solving abilities in mathematics. Given its usefulness, there is still little knowledge in the field about how it can afford such opportunities in real classrooms. In this study, an attempt was made to make in-depth observations of such classrooms from the perspective of variation. We examined the differences in the space of learning provided by two lessons of the same teacher in two Ethiopian primary school classrooms. Based on the literature, we identified three key aspects for analysis: mathematical tasks, lesson structure and classroom interaction patterns. Our analysis showed that, even though both lessons focused on the same topic of solving linear inequalities, they were enacted differently. The lesson that employed a PS-based MI approach constituted a wider space of learning than the lesson employing a conventional approach. This study demonstrates the usefulness of our analytical approach for describing and documenting PS-based MI practice, and for qualitatively interpreting the differences in what is mathematically made available to learn. We suggest that it can provide guidelines for mathematics teachers to reflect upon and to enhance learning spaces in their own classrooms.
"I'll just try to mimic that": an exploration of students' analogical structure creation in abstract algebra

Hicks, Michael D.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10649-024-10345-1

2024-08-23

Educational Studies in Mathematics

Abstract:Despite the prominence of analogies in mathematics, little attention has been given to exploring students' processes of analogical reasoning, and even less research exists on revealing how students might be empowered to independently and productively reason by analogy to establish new (to them) mathematics. I argue that the lack of a cohesive framework for interpreting students' approaches to analogical reasoning in mathematics contributes to this issue. To address this, I introduce the Analogical Reasoning in Mathematics (ARM) framework. Constructed from an analysis of interviews with four abstract algebra students, ARM identifies several analogical activities that serve to analyze students' analogical reasoning with a finer grain size than was previously possible with existing frameworks. Using this framework, I present an analysis of the students' constructions of a ring-theoretic analogy to subgroup, thus revealing that even constructing simple analogies can elicit diverse pathways of analogical reasoning across students. Implications for further research related to analogies and analogical reasoning in mathematics education are discussed.

education & educational research
Computational Thinking and The Algebra Project

Alan Shaw,Brian R. Lawler,William Crombie,Tom McKlin,Tamika Richards

DOI: https://doi.org/10.34024/prometeica.2023.27.15348

2023-07-27

Prometeica - Revista de Filosofía y Ciencias

Abstract:Through our work to examine mathematical and computational learning in authentic and convivial contexts that requires creativity, imagination, reasoning, and discourse, we have theorized an experiential learning cycle that attends to the development of voice, agency, and identity needed in young people for an earned insurgency—the right to demand change. Our work underscores how the current situation that many students face in classrooms amounts to a type of cognitive segregation that denies these students access to authentic and empowering intellectual agency. By facilitating a process whereby students, using their own creative and imaginative means, intentionally develop a type of ownership over the exploration and application of the mathematical concepts they are being taught, we help students move from simple surface level, syntactic understandings, to deeper semantic learning that is more personally significant and meaningful.
Student Inquiry and the Rascal Triangle

Philip K. Hotchkiss

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1907.07749

2019-07-18

Abstract:Those of us who teach Mathematics for Liberal Arts (MLA) courses often underestimate the mathematical abilities of the students enrolled in our courses. Despite the fact that many of these students suffer from math anxiety and will admit to hating mathematics, when we give them space to explore mathematics and bring their existing knowledge to the problem, they can make some amazing mathematical discoveries. Inquiry-based learning (IBL) is perfect structure to provide these type of opportunities. In this paper, we will examine one inquiry-based investigation in which MLA students were given the space to look for patterns which resulted in some original discoveries.

History and Overview
Flipping an Algebra Classroom: Analyzing, Modeling, and Solving Systems of Linear Equations

Rebecca Kirvan,Christopher R. Rakes,Regie Zamora

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07380569.2015.1093902

2015-10-02

Computers in the Schools

Abstract:The present study investigated whether flipping an algebra classroom led to a stronger focus on conceptual understanding and improved learning of systems of linear equations for 54 seventh- and eighth-grade students using teacher journal data and district-mandated unit exam items. Multivariate analysis of covariance was used to compare scores on three factors, analyze, model, and solve systems of linear equations. We found comparable statistically significant learning gains in both treatment groups. We found that the focus on conceptual understanding was similar in the flipped and control classrooms, and the learning gains were statistically significant and similar in both groups. Explicit attention to the substance of the at-home videos and in-class activities is needed to use the flipped classroom model to successfully shift the instructional focus from procedural to conceptual understanding.
Teaching Mathematics with a New Curriculum: Changes to Classroom Organization and Interactions

Gwendolyn M. Lloyd

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10986060701854482

2008-04-15

Mathematical Thinking and Learning

Abstract:This report describes a high school mathematics teacher's decisions about classroom organization and interactions during his first two years using a new curriculum intended to support teachers' development of student-centered, contributive classroom discourse. In year one, the teacher conducted class and interacted with students primarily in small groups. In year two, he conducted more whole-class instruction. In both years, teacher-student interactions contained univocal and contributive discourse, but in year two the teacher sustained contributive discourse with students for longer periods. The teacher facilitated the most significant changes to classroom discourse in the instructional format with which he had the greatest experience (whole-class instruction). Over the period of this study, two key factors appeared to affect the teacher's decisions about classroom organization and interactions: his perception of students' expectations about mathematics classroom roles and activity, and his own discomfort associated with using a new curriculum. These areas are important candidates for future research about teachers' use of innovative mathematics curricula.

education & educational research
Paramathematical notions and Klein's Plan B: the case of equations

Carl Winsløw

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2309.16690

2023-08-05

Abstract:Undergraduate students of mathematics continue to solve equations in virtually any course they attend, just as they did in secondary school -- yet what do they learn about equations and their solutions at university? Are they capable to combine elements of abstract algebra and real analysis to assess what it means to solve an equation, in particular, what it means for an equation to be solvable -- or not? In this paper, we present a mathematical and didactical analysis of these questions, illustrated by examples from a capstone course for future Danish high school teachers.

History and Overview
Classroom Conversation Analysis and Critical Reflective Practice: Self-evaluation of Teacher Talk Framework in Focus

Hajar Ghafarpour

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0033688216631173

2016-04-20

RELC Journal

Abstract:The uniqueness of the Language Classroom and its complexity raises a need for foreign language teachers to develop necessary skills and knowledge to observe, analyse and evaluate their classroom discourse. Hence, interactional awareness of language teachers is an integral part of pedagogical and practical knowledge. In this article, the Self-Evaluation of Teacher Talk framework (SETT) proposed by Walsh (2006) will be discussed in detail and its contribution to critical reflective practice will be probed. The extracts are taken from 12 hours of tape recording of a university General English course and supported by a teacher’s diary for analysis. The results demonstrate that although the SETT framework is representative and useful, setting and institutional requirements should not be ignored. This article has implications not only for developing critical reflective practice for in-service teachers but also for teacher training.

linguistics

Reflections on the Algebra I Classroom Introduction

Untangling Classroom Positionings: An Instrumental Case Unpacking Positioning Theory in Mathematics Education

The Nature and Quality of Algebra Instruction: Using a Content-Focused Observation Tool as a Lens for Understanding and Improving Instructional Practice

Restructuring for Mathematical Power: Techniques for Teaching Thinking in Algebra

“Our Voyage with Knowing and Teaching Elementary Mathematics”

Teaching Writing and Communication in a Mathematical Modeling Course

Including School Mathematics Teaching Applications in an Undergraduate Abstract Algebra Course

Math Confidence in an Elementary Mathematics Classroom

What Group Theory Can Do for You: From Magmas to Abstract Thinking in School Mathematics

Reflective journaling in mathematics: Insights into the development of future teachers

REFLECTIONS ON TASK-BASED LANGUAGE TEACHING

When Traditional Won't Do: Experiences from a “Lower-Level” Mathematics Classroom

Using Student Reflections to Develop Deep Teaching

Describing and Interpreting the Space of Classroom Learning in Problem-Solving-Based Mathematics Instruction: Variation as an Analytical Lens

"I'll just try to mimic that": an exploration of students' analogical structure creation in abstract algebra

Computational Thinking and The Algebra Project

Student Inquiry and the Rascal Triangle

Flipping an Algebra Classroom: Analyzing, Modeling, and Solving Systems of Linear Equations

Teaching Mathematics with a New Curriculum: Changes to Classroom Organization and Interactions

Paramathematical notions and Klein's Plan B: the case of equations

Classroom Conversation Analysis and Critical Reflective Practice: Self-evaluation of Teacher Talk Framework in Focus