Environmental Impact of Natural and Synthetic Astaxanthin Pigments Using Life Cycle Assessment

Beate Zlaugotne,Fabian Diaz,Jelena Pubule,Dagnija Blumberga

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4363420

2023-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:The growing demand for fish and the development of the industry raises concerns about environmental impacts. As fish production increases, so does the consumption of fish feed. One of the ingredients in fish feed is pigment, which improves the nutritional value and visual appearance of the product, increasing its marketability.Astaxanthin is a red pigment that also has high antioxidant activity. The feed may use natural pigment from microalgae or synthetic pigment. The advantage of natural pigment from microalgae is ecological benefits, as the microalgae culture can sequester carbon and release oxygen. The advantage of synthetic pigment is the economic aspect. The Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) method was used to determine the environmental impact of natural and synthetic pigments. The results obtained from the LCA are expressed according to the impact categories defined by the Product Environmental Footprint Category Rules (PEFCR). Sensitivity analysis was performed for natural pigment and changes were made only to electricity - electricity is produced by hydropower in Norway or used country mix from Norway. The total single score value for natural pigment is 6.85E+01 mPt and the largest impact is from the preparation of the culture medium phase - from sodium nitrate and magnesium sulfate. The sensitivity analysis results for electricity from the country mix is 4.50E+02 mPt. The total single score value for synthetic pigment is 1.07E-01 mPt and the largest impact is from methanol and electricity consumption. Synthetic pigments have a lower environmental impact than natural pigments, but a sensitivity analysis shows that the environmental impact can be reduced by choosing an alternative to electricity. It should be noted that the comparison presented represents a general comparison of alternatives, as the input data is derived from a literature review.