Abstract:Historically, change detection reviews have examined and categorized algorithms based on their techniques for the remote sensing community. Here, we synthesize urban land change algorithms by the types of information they provide to a diverse and growing set of user communities. Two goals of the paper are first to synthesize past and current change detection studies to examine urban land change to help users of remote sensing algorithms understand and navigate the vast variety of available methods, and second to identify gaps in knowledge for the urban remote sensing community. We analyzed 644 peer-reviewed research papers published in English-language journals and conducted a systematic review of urban land change algorithms. All papers included in our study focus on urban land change; studies that concentrate on single-date urban classification or mapping for one point in time without an explicit urban land change component are not included in this analysis. The review showed five key results and knowledge gaps. First, most urban change detection algorithms are being developed and applied for only a few regions, with 75% of studies focused on high or upper-middle-income countries and the majority of these on China or the United States. This suggests a major gap in geographic coverage as well as the need for more studies on cities in low and lower-middle-income countries. Second, the results show that 41% of the algorithms have been developed or applied for cities of over 5 million inhabitants. This focus on large cities is problematic given that only 11% of the world's urban population lives in cities with populations greater than 5 million and that most future urban growth will occur in small- and medium-sized towns and cities with populations of fewer than 1 million people. Third, our analysis shows that 62% of the studies use three or fewer time points to measure urban land change with an average study length of 17 years. Since rapidly growing urban areas are highly dynamic, this suggests that existing algorithms using only a few time points are likely missing urban transitions that can only be captured with high temporal frequency analysis. Fourth, we find that urban expansion is the most commonly monitored type of urban land change. Comparatively fewer studies characterized intra-urban change or three-dimensional structural change. Fifth and finally, the results show that an overwhelming majority—87%—of all studies identify only one urban class, highlighting a need for more studies that distinguish intra-urban variation and differentiate multiple urban classes. Our analysis shows that it is very difficult—nearly impossible—to compare across algorithms. Thus, for users of urban land change information, it is difficult to navigate the literature and know which algorithms are most appropriate for a particular use. Taken together, this points to the need for improved reproducibility, replicability, and comparability of studies in order to help harmonize urban land change information across regions and countries. This is especially important given the growing user communities of urban land change products and analysis, especially from policy and practice.

Performance analysis of change detection techniques for land use land cover

Change detection techniques for remote sensing applications: a survey

Change Detection and Feature Extraction Using High-Resolution Remote Sensing Images

Change Detection in Remote Sensing Image Data Comparing Algebraic and Machine Learning Methods

Detection of Spatial Changes using Spatial Data Mining

Application of Multi-Sensor Images for Detecting Land Cover Change and Analysis of Urban Expansion

Change Detection Methods for Remote Sensing in the Last Decade: A Comprehensive Review

Sub-Pixel Change Detection For Urban Land-Cover Analysis Via Multi-Temporal Remote Sensing Images

Soft Computing Techniques for Change Detection in remotely sensed images : A Review

Urban Land Use Change Detection Using Multisensor Satellite Images

A Method of Land Use/land Cover Change Detection from Remote Sensing Image Based on Support Vector Machines

A Method of Urban Change Detection Using High Spatial Resolution Remotely Sensed Data

A Systematic Review of Landsat Data for Change Detection Applications: 50 Years of Monitoring the Earth

Change Detection Based on Artificial Intelligence: State-of-the-Art and Challenges

Unsupervised Change Detection in HR Remote Sensing Imagery Based on Local Histogram Similarity and Progressive Otsu

Review Article Digital change detection techniques using remotely-sensed data

Deep Learning-based Land-cover Change Detection in Remote-sensing Imagery

Pca-Based Land-Use Change Detection and Analysis Using Multitemporal and Multisensor Satellite Data

A spectral gradient difference based approach for land cover change detection

Dual attention guided deep encoder-decoder network for change analysis in land use/land cover for Dakshina Kannada District, Karnataka, India

A systematic review and assessment of algorithms to detect, characterize, and monitor urban land change