Abstract:Objective: Confusion is the primary epistemic emotion in the learning process, influencing students' engagement and whether they become frustrated or bored. However, research on confusion in learning is still in its early stages, and there is a need to better understand how to recognize it and what EEG signals indicate its occurrence. The present work investigates confusion during reasoning learning using EEG, and aims to fill this gap with a multidisciplinary approach combining educational psychology, neuroscience and computer science. Approach: First, we design an experiment to actively and accurately induce confusion in reasoning. Second, we propose a subjective and objective joint labeling technique to address the label noise issue. Third, to confirm that the confused state can be distinguished from the non-confused state, we compare and analyze the mean band power of confused and unconfused states across five typical bands. Finally, we present an EEG database for confusion analysis, together with benchmark results from conventional (Naive Bayes, SVM, Random Forest, and ANN) and end-to-end (LSTM, ResNet, and EEGNet) machine learning methods. Main results: Findings revealed: 1. Significant differences in the power of delta, theta, alpha, beta and lower gamma between confused and non-confused conditions; 2. A higher attentional and cognitive load when participants were confused; and 3. The Random Forest algorithm with time-domain features achieved a high accuracy/F1 score (88.06%/0.88 for the subject-dependent approach and 84.43%/0.84 for the subject-independent approach) in the binary classification of the confused and non-confused states. Significance: The study advances our understanding of confusion and provides practical insights for recognizing and analyzing it in the learning process. It extends existing theories on the differences between confused and non-confused states during learning and contributes to the cognitive-affective model. The research enables researchers, educators, and practitioners to monitor confusion, develop adaptive systems, and test recognition approaches.

Detecting the Confusion of Students in Massive Open Online Courses Using EEG

Unifying Application and Adaptative Patterns for Confused student EEG Signals Classification

Recognition of Hypoxia EEG with a Preset Confidence Level Based on EEG Analysis.

ON THE CLASSIFICATION OF STUDENTS' CONFUSION DURING THE ONLINE EDUCATION PROCESS USING MACHINE LEARNING METHODS

Confused or not: decoding brain activity and recognizing confusion in reasoning learning using EEG

Prediction of Cognitive Load from Electroencephalography Signals Using Long Short-Term Memory Network

Early detection of serious but struggling learners in MOOCs using ensemble deep learning

A LSTM Network-based Learners’ Monitoring Model for Academic Self-efficacy Evaluation Using EEG Signal Analysis

Emotional Monitoring of Learners Based on EEG Signal Recognition

Predicting Stress in Remote Learning via Advanced Deep Learning Technologies

Classification of EEG Signals using Deep Learning

Know Your Mind: Adaptive Brain Signal Classification with Reinforced Attentive Convolutional Neural Networks

Deep Learning-Based Assessment Model for Real-Time Identification of Visual Learners Using Raw EEG

Predicting Cognitive Presence in At-Scale Online Learning: MOOC and For-Credit Online Course Environments

The Automatic Detection of Cognition Using EEG and Facial Expressions

Decoding Brain Signals from Rapid-Event EEG for Visual Analysis Using Deep Learning

Predicting and Understanding Student Learning Performance Using Multi-source Sparse Attention Convolutional Neural Networks

Data-driven learning fatigue detection system: A multimodal fusion approach of ECG (electrocardiogram) and video signals

ODL-BCI: Optimal deep learning model for brain-computer interface to classify students confusion via hyperparameter tuning

Predicting learning status in MOOCs using LSTM