Grounds for criminalization violation of the inviolability of the home under Art. 162 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine

Anton Rone
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36695/2219-5521.1.2021.55
2021-05-05
Law Review of Kyiv University of Law
Abstract:The article considers the grounds for criminalizing the violation of the inviolability of housing. The issue of improving the criminallaw protection of the inviolability of housing has been studied, in particular in terms of the grounds for criminalization of such actsas illegal occupation of someone else’s housing and its illegal maintenance. The following grounds for criminalization of violation ofthe inviolability of housing are analyzed: public danger of the act; the ratio of positive and negative consequences of criminal liability;ensuring by the state the protection of the constitutional rights and freedoms of man and citizen provided for in Section II of the Cons -titution of Ukraine. Criminal liability is the most severe type of legal liability, which leads to the conclusion that the legislator assessesthe violation of the inviolability of housing as an act, the commission of which on its own merits entails criminal liability, not less severetypes of legal liability.It is determined that the inviolability of housing has an important public value, which determines its protection by means of statecoercion. State coercion can be defined as a method of state influence on the consciousness and behavior of persons and property ofsubjects of legal relations, in order to ensure proper exercise of rights, prevention of offenses, punishment and correction of offenders,restoration of violated rights, applied by state bodies in accordance with their competence regardless of the will and desire of legallybound entities.Given the variety of acts covered by the provisions of Part 1 of Art. 162 of the Criminal Code, which include acts that can becommitted by a common subject - an individual (illegal entry into housing or other property of a person, illegal eviction or other actsthat violate the inviolability of housing) and special sub ‘ subject - a law enforcement official on behalf of the state (illegal inspectionor search), from this point of view, the inviolability of housing is a social value that is subject to protection from unlawful encroachmentsby other persons and by the state in the person of a law enforcement representative.It is determined that although the grounds for criminalization should be considered together, taking into account all possiblegrounds for criminalization is not mandatory, especially in light of the various classifications defined in the literature, at least most ofthem are sufficient to address the feasibility of criminalizing an act. In view of this, in our opinion, it is impossible to agree with theposition of some researchers that the state’s fulfillment of obligations under international agreements is one of the grounds for criminalizingthe violation of the inviolability of housing.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?