Abstract:Air cleaning techniques have been applied worldwide with the goal of improving indoor air quality. The effectiveness of applying these techniques varies widely, and pollutant removal efficiency is usually determined in controlled laboratory environments which may not be realized in practice. Some air cleaners are largely ineffective, and some produce harmful by-products. To summarize what is known regarding the effectiveness of fan-driven air cleaning technologies, a state-of-the-art review of the scientific literature was undertaken by a multidisciplinary panel of experts from Europe, North America, and Asia with expertise in air cleaning, aerosol science, medicine, chemistry and ventilation. The effects on health were not examined. Over 26,000 articles were identified in major literature databases; 400 were selected as being relevant based on their titles and abstracts by the first two authors, who further reduced the number of articles to 160 based on the full texts. These articles were reviewed by the panel using predefined inclusion criteria during their first meeting. Additions were also made by the panel. Of these, 133 articles were finally selected for detailed review. Each article was assessed independently by two members of the panel and then judged by the entire panel during a consensus meeting. During this process 59 articles were deemed conclusive and their results were used for final reporting at their second meeting. The conclusions are that: (1) None of the reviewed technologies was able to effectively remove all indoor pollutants and many were found to generate undesirable by-products during operation. (2) Particle filtration and sorption of gaseous pollutants were among the most effective air cleaning technologies, but there is insufficient information regarding long-term performance and proper maintenance. (3) The existing data make it difficult to extract information such as Clean Air Delivery Rate (CADR), which represents a common benchmark for comparing the performance of different air cleaning technologies. (4) To compare and select suitable indoor air cleaning devices, a labeling system accounting for characteristics such as CADR, energy consumption, volume, harmful by-products, and life span is necessary. For that purpose, a standard test room and condition should be built and studied. (5) Although there is evidence that some air cleaning technologies improve indoor air quality, further research is needed before any of them can be confidently recommended for use in indoor environments.

Calculate modeling of the level of indoor air pollution during its cleaning with air purifiers

Indoor air quality improvement with filtration and UV-C on mitigation of particulate matter and airborne bacteria: Monitoring and modeling.

Exploring the long-term performance of air purifiers in removing particulate matter and formaldehyde across different residential environments

Using Low-cost Sensors to Quantify the Effects of Air Filtration on Indoor and Personal Exposure Relevant PM2.5 Concentrations in Beijing, China

Computational Fluid Dynamics-Based Calculation of Aerosol Transport in a Classroom with Window Ventilation, Mechanical Ventilation and Mobile Air Purifier

Numerical Analysis for Evaluating the "exposure Reduction Effectiveness" of Room Air Cleaners

Observationally Constrained Mass Balance Box Model Analysis of Aerosol Mitigation Potential Using Fan Powered Filters

A comparative study of the effects of ventilation-purification strategies on air quality and energy consumption in Beijing, China

Indoor Airflow and Pollutant Spread Inside the Cleanroom with Micro-Porous Supplying Panel and Different Ventilation Schemes: Analytical, Numerical and Experimental Investigations

Environmentally friendly and energy-self-sufficiency-based air purifier: an approach for mitigating outdoor particulate matter

Can commonly-used fan-driven air cleaning technologies improve indoor air quality? A literature review

Particulate Pollution in Ventilated Space: Analysis of Influencing Factors.

A systematic review and meta-analysis of field studies of portable air cleaners: Performance, user behavior, and by-product emissions

An evaluation model of indoor PM2.5 dynamic characteristics considering human activities

Health benefit/burden, PM2.5 removal effectiveness, and power consumption based comparison of common residential air‐cleaning technologies in the United States

Numerical investigation of indoor air quality in a floor heated room with different air change rates

Cost-effective Analysis of Different Intervention Scenarios with Air Cleaners to Reduce the Exposure to Fine Particulate Matters in China

Development of air purifier operation guidelines using grey box models for the concentrations of particulate matter in elementary school classrooms

Real‐time measurements of PM 2.5 and ozone to assess the effectiveness of residential indoor air filtration in Shanghai homes

Air Pollution and Pulmonary Health: Effects of Short-Term Indoor Air Quality Intervention with Portable Air Purifier

Performance of three air distribution systems in VOC removal from an area source