Abstract:Climate risks are now fully recognized as financial risks by asset managers, investors, central banks, and financial supervisors. Against this background, a rapidly growing number of market participants and financial authorities are exploring which metrics to use to capture climate risks, as well as to what extent the use of different metrics delivers heterogeneous results. To shed a light on these questions, we analyse a sample of 69 transition risk metrics delivered by 9 different climate transition risk providers and covering the 1,500 firms of the MSCI World index. Our findings show that convergence between metrics is significantly higher for the firms most exposed to transition risk. We also show that metrics with similar scenarios (i.e. horizon, temperature target and transition paths) tend to deliver more coherent risk assessments. Turning to the variables that might drive the outcome of the risk assessment, we find evidence that variables on metric’s assumptions and scenario’s characteristics are associated with changes in the estimated firms’ transition risk. Our findings bear important implications for policy making and research. First, climate transition risk metrics, if applied by the majority of financial market participants in their risk assessment, might translate into relatively coherent market pricing signals for least and most exposed firms. Second, it would help the correct interpretation of metrics in financial markets if supervisory authorities defined a joint baseline approach to ensure basic comparability of disclosed metrics, and asked for detailed assumption documentations alongside the metrics. Third, researchers should start to justify the use of the specific climate risk metrics and interpret their findings in the light of the metric assumptions.

The impact of climate transition risks on financial stability. A systemic risk approach.

Systemic risk effects of climate transition on financial stability

Climate risks and financial stability: Evidence from the European financial system

Systemic Climate Risk

Accounting for climate transition risk in banks' capital requirements

Climate transition risk, profitability and stock prices

Climate Change and the Financial System

The double materiality of climate physical and transition risks in the euro area

CLIMATE CHANGE AND FISCAL SUSTAINABILITY: RISKS AND OPPORTUNITIES

Climate Transition Risk Metrics: Understanding Convergence and Divergence across Firms and Providers.

An analytical framework for assessing climate transition risks: an application to France

Financial stability, stranded assets and the low‐carbon transition – A critical review of the theoretical and applied literatures

Measuring Transition Risk in Investment Funds

Dynamic impact of climate risks on financial systemic risk: Evidence from China

Transition versus physical climate risk pricing in European financial markets: a text-based approach

Enabling or Hampering? Climate Risk and the Role of Finance in the Low-Carbon Transition

The Low-Carbon Transition, Climate Commitments and Firm Credit Risk

Climate transition risk in determining credit risk: evidence from firms listed on the STOXX Europe 600 index

Climate Risk and the Systemic Risk of Banks: A Global Perspective

Climate Change Transition Risk on Sovereign Bond Markets

A Climate Stress-Test of the Financial System