Guest Editorial: Will the Ukraine War Derail Europe’s Energy Transition?

Hari Vamadevan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2118/0622-0010-jpt
2022-06-01
Journal of Petroleum Technology
Abstract:As Europe struggles to balance energy security and energy independence following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, uncertainty looms. By turning its back on Russian oil and gas, will Europe speed up or slow down its energy transition, and what will be the impact on the global climate change crisis? These are complicated questions that require a whole-system view and depend on the extent and duration of the war. Energy Security European policymakers are determined to slash the EU’s Russian gas dependence by two-thirds this year—a tall order. The replacement will be painful and costly, with increased LNG imports taking center stage. Energy security ambition hinges on additional policies such as the International Energy Agency’s 10-point plan recommendations. Beyond nudging consumer behavior toward lower energy use, there is scope for a concerted policy push for energy efficiency, a postponement of nuclear retirements, and extensive renewable energy buildout. Nonfossil supply and energy efficiency will accelerate; however, counterforces are at work: burning more coal to replace natural gas; and the increasing cost of electric vehicle (EV) batteries and solar photovoltaic (PV) panels through higher commodity prices. To this extent, the push for energy security works against the transition. Modeling the Transition DNV’s system dynamics energy transition model provides insight on how economics, technologies, sectors, geographies, and policies influence one another. The model assessed how the changes seen since 24 February 2022 could influence Europe’s energy transition. Significant uncertainties fall from the war’s duration, possible escalation, and whether strengthened countermeasures completely stop the export of Russian oil and gas to the continent. Europe’s Fit for 55 climate plan commitment will likely endure, though public reaction to energy affordability may challenge its momentum in the short term and other imponderables remain: Will a new cold war emerge or a calmer détente result? With these in mind, we modeled a scenario where Europe’s energy system discontinues Russian gas imports, with zero Russian gas from 2025 onward.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?