Abstract:Spaced learning has been shown consistently to benefit memory compared with massed learning, yet the neural representations and processes underlying the spacing effect are still poorly understood. In particular, two influential models (i.e., the encoding variability hypothesis and the study-phase retrieval hypothesis) could both model behavioral performance very well, but they make opposite hypotheses regarding the spacing effect's neural mechanisms. The present study attempted to provide empirical neural evidence to adjudicate these competing hypotheses. Using spatiotemporal pattern similarity (STPS) analysis of EEG data, this study investigated whether and how repetition lags (massed/short-spaced/long-spaced) modulated the STPS's contribution to episodic memory encoding in male and female human participants. The results revealed that greater item-specific STPS in the right frontal electrodes at 543-727 ms after stimulus onset was associated with better memory performance. More importantly, this STPS was larger under the spaced-learning condition than the massed-learning condition and partially mediated the spacing effect on memory performance. In addition, we found that massed learning was associated with stronger repetition suppression in the N400 component that reflected momentary retrieval strength, but reduced activity in the late positive component that was associated with memory retrieval. These results suggest that spaced learning improves long-term memory by increasing retrieval effort and enhancing the pattern reinstatement of prior neural representations, which may be achieved by reducing the momentary retrieval strength as the extended repetition lags might help to eliminate the residual representation in working memory.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT As one of the most ubiquitous and fundamental phenomena in the history of memory research, the spacing effect provides an important window into understanding how enduring memory is formed in the brain and how different practice strategies could modulate these mechanisms to affect memory performance. By leveraging the neural representational analysis on scalp EEG data, the current study provides the first empirical data to show that spaced learning enhances memory by improving the spatiotemporal similarity that occurs at a late time window. Our results support the study-phase retrieval hypothesis but not the encoding variability hypothesis and emphasize the role of neural pattern reinstatement in strengthening memory via repeated study.

The science of effective learning with spacing and retrieval practice

Spaced Learning Enhances Episodic Memory by Increasing Neural Pattern Similarity Across Repetitions.

Active recall strategies associated with academic achievement in young adults: A systematic review

Scaling Effective Learning Strategies: Retrieval Practice and Long-Term Knowledge Retention in MOOCs

Word learning by children with developmental language disorder: Identifying gaps in our understanding of spaced retrieval effects

Distributed Practice or Spacing Effect

Why do learners ignore expected feedback in making metacognitive decisions about retrieval practice?

Spacing, Feedback, and Testing Boost Vocabulary Learning in a Web Application

Retrieval Practice and Study Planning in MOOCs: Exploring Classroom-Based Self-regulated Learning Strategies at Scale

Retrieval Practice and Word Learning by Children With Developmental Language Disorder: Does Expanding Retrieval Provide Additional Benefit?

Strategy Selection under Metacognitive Monitoring and the Practical Implications for Self -Regulated Learning of College English

The optimal learning strategy depends on learning goals and processes: Retrieval practice versus worked examples.

Retrieval Practice in Classroom Settings: A Review of Applied Research

Neural mechanisms of the spacing effect in episodic memory: A parallel EEG and fMRI study

The Testing Effect in University Teaching: Using Multiple-Choice Testing to Promote Retention of Highly Retrievable Information

Unbounded Human Learning: Optimal Scheduling for Spaced Repetition

Study Smarter: Applying the Science of Learning to Radiology

Promoting retrieval practice use during self‐study in higher education: The effects of a compact strategy intervention with metacognitive support

Low-Stakes Quizzes Improve Learning and Reduce Overconfidence in College Students

The Effect of Subtitling on the Learning Effectiveness of Second Language Acquisition

An Evidence-Based Guide for Medical Students: How to Optimize the Use of Expanded-Retrieval Platforms