Abstract:BackgroundThough active-learning instruction has the potential to positively impact the preparation and diversity of STEM graduates, not all instructors are able to achieve this potential. One important factor is the teacher knowledge that instructors possess, including their pedagogical knowledge. Pedagogical knowledge is the knowledge about teaching and learning that is not topic-specific, such as knowledge of learning theory, classroom management, and student motivation. We investigated the pedagogical knowledge that 77 instructors who report implementing active-learning instruction used as they analyzed video clips of lessons in large active-learning biology courses. We used qualitative content analysis, and drew on cognitive and sociocultural perspectives of learning, to identify and characterize the pedagogical knowledge instructors employed. We used the collective thinking of these instructors to generate a framework of pedagogical knowledge for active-learning instruction in large undergraduate biology courses.ResultsWe identified seven distinct components of pedagogical knowledge, as well as connections among these components. At the core of their thinking, participants evaluated whether instruction provided opportunities for students to generate ideas beyond what was presented to them and to engage in scientific practices. They also commonly considered student motivation to engage in this work and how instruction maximized equity among students. Participants noticed whether instructors monitored and responded to student thinking in real-time, how instruction prompted metacognition, and how links were built between learning tasks. Participants also thought carefully about managing the logistics of active-learning lessons.ConclusionsInstructors who report using active-learning instruction displayed knowledge of principles of how people learn, practical knowledge of teaching strategies and behaviors, and knowledge related to classroom management. Their deep knowledge of pedagogy suggests that active-learning instruction requires much more than content knowledge built through training in the discipline, yet many college STEM instructors have little or no training in teaching. Further research should test this framework of pedagogical knowledge in different instruction contexts, including different STEM disciplines. Additional research is needed to understand what teacher knowledge is critical to effective active-learning instruction and how the development of this knowledge is best facilitated. Achieving widespread improvement in undergraduate STEM education will likely require transforming our approach to preparing and supporting undergraduate instructors.

From the Front lines of active learning: Lessons learned from those who are trying

Active learning strategies for an effective mathematics teaching and learning

Active Learning in Secondary School Mathematics

Observing Instructor Behaviour in an Active Learning Classroom: A Case Study of an Undergraduate Calculus Course

Evidence-based teaching: how do we all get there?

Pedagogical knowledge for active-learning instruction in large undergraduate biology courses: a large-scale qualitative investigation of instructor thinking

When Active Learning Is Inequitable: Women’s Participation Predicts Gender Inequities in Mathematical Performance

Active learning narrows achievement gaps for underrepresented students in undergraduate science, technology, engineering, and math

Challenges and motivation for teachers transitioning to active learning spaces

Facilitating collaboration between mathematics methods and content faculty through cross-departmental lesson study

Integrating the anthropological theory of didactics in multivariate calculus education: Challenges, pedagogical shifts, and innovative activities

Preparing Elementary School Teachers to Learn From Teaching: A Comparison of Two Approaches to Mathematics Methods Instruction

Teacher Knowledge for Active-Learning Instruction: Expert–Novice Comparison Reveals Differences

Using Plan-Do-Study-Act Cycles and Interdisciplinary Conversations to Transform Introductory Mathematics Courses

Barriers to Active Learning for Computer Science Faculty

Does Theory Translate into Practice? An Observational Study of Current Mathematics Pedagogies in Play-Based Kindergarten

Facing Challenges in Remote Mathematics Education and Support by building a Community of Practice around Student-Staff Partnership

Blended Learning and Student-centered Active Learning Environment: a Case Study with STEM Undergraduate Students

Tackling the Gender Gap in Mathematics with Active Learning Methodologies

Beyond active learning: Using 3-Dimensional learning to create scientifically authentic, student-centered classrooms