Abstract:The main objective of this article is to analyze the cognitive level of the activities in History textbooks in Spain, England, and Portugal in the transition stage from Primary to Secondary Education (11-13 years), according to the country of origin, typology, and the concepts and disciplinary contents included. The design of this research is quantitative, descriptive, and cross-sectional. The non-probabilistic sample consists of 6,561 activities contained in 27 school textbooks from Spain, England, and Portugal. Descriptive and contrast analyses have been carried out using parametric tests. The results indicate that textbooks from Spain and Portugal mainly include activities situated between a basic and intermediate cognitive level while in England, the cognitive level of activities is medium or high. The ANOVA and Tukey B tests show significant differences between the cognitive level required in the activities and the typology of exercises, the concepts, and historical contents worked on. The activities with higher cognitive level correspond to those of creation and essays, the exercises that work on empathy and historical relevance, and that contain activities of social and economic history. In contrast, the activities with the lowest cognitive level are short questions and objective tests, those that work on first-order concepts (data and concrete facts), and those on the History of Art. The conclusion is that there is a need for a balanced presence of first-order content and historical thinking skills, the application in the classroom of a more active student-centered methodology, and the teachers' conception of history teaching that prioritizes historical skills.

Thinking skills in Primary Education: An Analysis of CLIL Textbooks in Spain

Primary School Teachers’ Perceptions of the Level of Development of Low-Order Cognitive Skills Under the Content and Language Integrated Learning Approach

CLIL teachers’ views on cognitive development in primary education

A rubric model to analyse CLIL textbooks in Primary Education

Development of Critical and Creative Thinking Skills in CLIL

Analysis of Cognitive Skills in History Textbook (Spain-England-Portugal)

Effective questioning in CLIL classrooms: empowering thinking

Analysing CLIL Teacher Competences in Pre-service Preschool Education. A Case Study at the University of Granada

Analysing students’ content-learning in science in CLIL vs. non-CLIL programmes: empirical evidence from Spain

Student-teacher interaction in CLIL and non-CLIL elementary education

CONTENT AND LANGUAGE INTEGRATED LEARNING (CLIL) TO DEVELOP WRITING SKILLS IN ENGLISH.

Assessment in CLIL: Test development for content and language for teaching natural science in English as a foreign language

The impact of CLIL on the acquisition of L2 competences and skills in primary education

CLIL methodology, materials and resources, and assessment in a monolingual context: an analysis of stakeholders’ perceptions in Andalusia

Spokes in the Wheels of CLIL for Multilingualism or How Monolingual Ideologies Limit Teacher Training

ENGLISH TEACHERS IN CLIL SECONDARY SCHOOLS IN MADRID: BELIEFS, ATTITUDES AND KNOWLEDGE

CLIL: the approach for the future?

Building Scientific Knowledge in English: Integrating Content, Cognition and Communication in Secondary School CLIL Biology

Analysis of CLIL-Related Research in School Settings: A Systematic Review

Promoting children’s creative thinking through reading and writing in a cooperative learning classroom

The impact of CLIL on English language competence in a monolingual context: a longitudinal perspective