Reviewing an Paper for Tourism and Hospitality—A Peep behind the Curtain

Brian Garrod
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/tourhosp3040054
2022-10-18
Tourism and Hospitality
Abstract:Academic journals rely crucially upon the willingness of academics to review papers and for them to provide high-quality review reports. The purpose of this Editorial is to assist reviewers for Tourism and Hospitality in providing review reports that will be helpful to the journal editors in making decisions about whether to accept, reject or require revisions to papers that are submitted to the journal. It provides reviewers with a ‘peep behind the curtain’ of what can sometimes seem a rather opaque paper review process, with the aim of clarifying the purpose and format of the review process, and thereby to gain a greater appreciation of what it required of them. Several tips for writing high-quality review reports are also presented.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?