Learning Environment Quality for Medical Students at Umm Al-Qura University: A Comprehensive Study on Stressors, Sources, and Solutions After Introduction of a New Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery (MBBS) Curriculum
Amna Alotiby,Murouj Almaghrabi,Rawan Alosaimy,Amjad Alharthi,Bashaer Khawandanah,Ruba Alansari,Ahaad Basahal,Ghofran Zamil
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/AMEP.S343792
2022-01-19
Advances in Medical Education and Practice
Abstract:Amna Alotiby, 1 Murouj Almaghrabi, 2 Rawan Alosaimy, 2 Amjad Alharthi, 2 Bashaer Khawandanah, 2 Ruba Alansari, 2 Ahaad Basahal, 2 Ghofran Zamil 2 1 Department of Hematology and Immunology, Faculty of Medicine, Umm Al-Qura University, Makkah, Saudi Arabia; 2 Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Umm Al-Qura University, Makkah, Saudi Arabia Correspondence: Amna Alotiby Department of Hematology and Immunology, Faculty of Medicine, Umm Al-Qura University, Makkah, Saudi Arabia Email Objective: Due to introduction of a new curriculum and the related stressors that medical students might encounter, we aimed to assess the quality of the students' learning environment across academic years at Umm Al-Qura University (UQU), by evaluating stress levels, their sources, and impacts on students, to help improve the quality of learning environment and protect students from personal and academic burnout. Methods: We conducted a descriptive cross-sectional study in August and September of 2020 on 572 students enrolled in the new Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery (MBBS) curriculum at UQU. All statistical analyses were performed using SPSS software and two-tailed tests. Results: In total, 46.5% of participants encountered severe stress levels during their studies at UQU. In term of stressor sources, the highest prevalence of severe stress was found among students who lacked learning resources (68.8%), followed by those who complained of ambiguity in teaching, learning, and assessment strategies (64.1%). Self-study strategy issues (58.4%) and difficulty in reading textbooks (58.2%) also ranked high. Anxiety was often reported by the students as an impact of stress (62.9%), followed by mood swings (60%). Severe stress levels showed a statistically significant relationship to gender, being highest among females (P = 0.001). For a solution to manage the stress, 79% of the students suggested a supportive learning environment and identification of students' struggles at early stages. Conclusion: Almost half the medical students were severely stressed after the new curriculum was introduced. Therefore, professors and universities should look out for potential stressors and help students overcome them. Universities can also help by offering counseling services to students, improving the student tutoring system, providing appropriate learning environment and resources, and including stress management courses as a part of the overall curriculum. Keywords: medical students, stress, curriculum change, learning environment, teaching styles, medical school Stress is a mental, emotional, or physical response to environmental challenges and threats that cause mental or physical tension. 1 In particular, the educational environment may impose stress challenges. Slight stress is normal and may increase productivity in certain individuals. However, extremely high levels of stress experienced over a long period can cause significant mental and physical issues, such as poor academic performance, reduced commitment, stress-related anxiety, depression, drug usage, and even suicidal thoughts. 2,3 Tertiary education has always been considered a stressful environment for students. Medical education adds to an already stressful environment. 4,5 Medical students encounter many stressors during their journey to achieve their goals; 5 these include an extensive medical curriculum, information overload, long study hours, high academic and family expectations, competition, and frequent and varied examinations. 3 Several studies have reported moderate to high levels of stress among medical students in different countries worldwide, including 91.1% in India, 6 84.5% in Pakistan, 7 83.5% in Thailand, 8 and 49% in Malaysia. 9 In Saudi Arabia, stress was reported in Imam Abdulrahman Bin Faisal University, Dammam, at 67.9% in 2018, 5 in Rabigh Medical College, Jeddah, at 59.2% in 2015, 3 in Umm Al-Qura University (UQU), Makkah, at 70.9% in 2015, 10 and in King Saud University, Riyadh, at 63% in 2011. 11 A previous study performed at UQU suggests the causes of distress to be the following factors: large volumes of information that must be retained, students' academic competition, grade point average (GPA), and fear of failure. These factors may be accentuated in the preclinical years, when coursework units are more theoretical. 10 Another study at UQU medical school found that the majority of students were dissatisfied with the passive, lecture-based method of teaching and wanted to see introduction of the concepts of -Abstract Truncated-