Abstract:Engineering ethics is a required aspect of accredited ABET programs, but there is widespread variation in how ethics is taught, to what ends, and how those ends are assessed. This variation makes it challenging to identify practices for teaching ethics to engineers aligned with extant practices in the field. In this study, we revise a recent coding framework by reviewing exemplary engineering ethics programs recognized by the National Academy of Engineering in 2016, or what we refer to as "exemplars." We pursue two primary objectives: (1) To apply and revise a prior coding framework to codify ethics learning objectives, instructional strategies, and assessment strategies in engineering education; and (2) To use the revised coding framework to identify trends in learning objectives, instructional strategies, and assessment strategies of NAE exemplars. We employ systemic review procedures to update the coding framework using 24 of 25 exemplars as a data source. The updated framework includes four primary categories associated with learning objectives, instructional strategies, assessment data collection strategies, and assessment design characteristics. Results indicate that ethical sensitivity or awareness was present in every exemplar as a learning objective, often alongside ethical reasoning-based learning objectives and the formation of professional skills. Exemplars employed numerous instructional strategies in tandem, as we coded eight out of 18 instructional strategies among at least half of the exemplars. Assignments/homework and summative reflections were the most oft-used sources of assessment data. Due to our challenges in coding assessment approaches, we offer practical suggestions for assessing engineering ethics instruction which are based on many of our coding discussions. We hope that this coding framework, the results classifying exemplary features of the NAE programs, and our practical suggestions can guide future instructors as they design, classify, assess, and report their approaches to engineering ethics education.

Assessing Ethical Sensitivity Development in Undergraduate Engineering Students

UNDERSTANDING THE INTERPRETATON, IMPLEMENTATION, AND IMPACT OF ENGINEERING ETHICS EDUCATION IN CANADA

Ethical Preparedness, Self-Efficacy and Challenges in Engineering Education – A Quantitative Study

Engineering Student’s Ethical Awareness and Behavior: A New Motivational Model

Ethics as an outcome of out-of-class engagement across diverse groups of engineering students

Ethics in Engineering Students' Design Considerations: Case Studies of Elec- tric Power Systems for the "Developing World"

Assessment of ethical sensitivity in nursing students: Tools, trends, and implications

Perceptions of Engineers' Environmental Responsibility and Professional Codes of Ethics

Student-inspired activities for the teaching and learning of engineering ethics

The importance of formative assessment in science and engineering ethics education: some evidence and practical advice

Diagnostic Evaluation of the Contribution of Complementary Training Subjects in the Self-Perception of Competencies in Ethics, Social Responsibility, and Sustainability in Engineering Students

A Multi-level Review of Engineering Ethics Education: Towards a Socio-technical Orientation of Engineering Education for Ethics

A Systematic Review of the 2016 National Academy of Engineering Exemplary Ethics Programs: Revisions to a Coding Framework

A Systematic Literature Review of US Engineering Ethics Interventions

A feasibility study for inclusion of ethics and social issues in engineering and design coursework in Australia

Freshmen Engineering Students’ Perspectives on Engineering Ethics – A Qualitative Study

Analyzing Sustainability Awareness and Professional Ethics of Civil Engineering Bachelor’s Degree Students

The Moral Foundations of Chinese Engineering Students: A Preliminary Investigation

Impact of Ethical Awareness on Engineering Identity Formation Using Ordinary Least Squares Analysis

Developing emotionally competent engineers for the ever-changing built environment

Decentring engineering education beyond the technical dimension: ethical skills framework