Abstract:We note the absence of prior literature on analytical structures to be used for China and other economies with extensive SOEs when evaluating behavioural responses of SOEs to trade policy and other changes. This is despite both the large empirical literature discussing the productivity effects of Chinese SOE enterprise reform, and wider policy discussion of the potential impacts of various reform initiatives. We present two simple analytical formulations of SOE behaviour in response to trade policy change with the aim of investigating how traditional competitive models of enterprise behaviour can mislead when used in policy debate. One formulation centres on SOE managerial control. In this enterprise managers are politically appointed, expect any non performing loans to be recapitalized by state banks andhence capital is centrally allocated by credit rationing. The managers are assured to maximize the size of the enterprise rather than profits since this yields maximal networking benefits to managers. This implies labour is priced at its average rather than its marginal product, and with a competitive non-manufacturing (agricultural) industry free trade is not optimal policy. The other assumes worker control of SOEs and that workers satisfice in their supply of effort to the enterprise given both fixed wage rates and enterprise employment and otherwise shirk or pursue second jobs. In this formulation the enterprise meets their budget constraint and covers costs. With leisure in the preferences of enterprise members, their leisure consumption will be implied by the satisfying behaviour of the enterprise and will be non optimal. In both model variants, implications for trade policy are different from those of a standard competitive model, and computations using models calibrated to 2003 Chinese data suggest the differences can be large.

Soft Budget Constraint, Strategic Delegation and Overcapacity of Chinese SOE

Defining the Optimal Space of China Industrial Policy——Subsidy Effect, Competition Compatible and Overcapacity Solution

A study of the impact of de-capacity policies on industry capacity utilization paths: Evidence from the Chinese steel industry

The Chinese‐style Macroeconomic Control: the Role of State‐owned Enterprises

Impact of product heterogeneity and soft budget constraint on excess capacity in Chinese energy industry based on the duopoly model

Does Public Money Drive out Private? Evidence from Government Regulations of Industrial Overcapacity Governance in Urban China

Policy Burden,Moral Hazard and Soft Budget Constraint

Chinese State-Owned Companies, Misallocation and the Reform Policy

Policy Burden of State-Owned Enterprises and Efficiency of Credit Resource Allocation: Evidence from China

SOE Shareholding Reform,Product Subsidy and Import Tariff: An Analysis Based on Mixed Oligopoly Theory

International Institutions, Soft Budget Constraint and Credible Commitments——China's Accession to WTO and the Political Logic of the Reform of State-owned Enterprises

Decentralization, Strategic Policy Burdens and the SOE Reforms in China – Theory and Evidence

The Soft Budget Constraint in China

Would the market mechanism cause the formation of overcapacity?: Evidence from Chinese listed firms of manufacturing industry

How to Explain Corporate Investment Heterogeneity in China's New Normal: Structural Models with State-Owned Property Rights

State-Owned Enterprise Behaviour Responses to Trade Reforms: Some Analytics and Numerical Simulation Results Using Chinese Data

Do the policy burdens of state-owned enterprises affect the efficiency of resource allocation of tax incentives?

Financial repression, SOE reform and fiscal-monetary policy coordination

Duopoly, mixed ownership, and the optimal proportion of employee stocks in state‐owned enterprises in China

SOEs and Soft Incentive Constraints in State Bank Lending

Selective Industrial Policy and Overcapacity: Evidence from a Quasi-Natural Experiment in China