Incidence of active tuberculosis in individuals with latent tuberculosis infection in rural China: follow-up results of a population-based, multicentre, prospective cohort study
Lei Gao,Xiangwei Li,Jianmin Liu,Xinhua Wang,Wei Lu,Liqiong Bai,Henan Xin,Haoran Zhang,Hengjing Li,Zongde Zhang,Yu Ma,Mufei Li,Boxuan Feng,Jiang Du,Hongtao Sui,Rong Zhao,Haoxiang Su,Shouguo Pan,Ling Guan,Fei Shen,Jian He,Shumin Yang,Hongyan Si,Xu Cheng,Zuhui Xu,Yunhong Tan,Tianzhu Chen,Weiguo Xu,Hong Peng,Zhijian Wang,Tao Zhu,Xiaoyou Chen,Xinhua Zhou,Xueling Guan,Qi Jin,LATENTTB-NSTM study team,Wen Kong,Cheng Chen,Yuejin Wang,Fengqiu Gong,Lili Guo,Zhonghui Huang,Wenjuan Shao,Ping Sun,Chunhua Xue,Yiqing Zhu,Weiping Jiang,Yaxiang Gui,Hao Wang,Ping Yang,Ruiyong Yao,Wenhua Yin,Nong Chao,Tao Jiang,Baima Village Qinxiao Qian,Hongqin Shi,Yungen Tao,Meiqin Wu,Yuping Yang,Dongmei Zhang,Guoxian Zhang,Jianguo Wang,Xiaojun Chen,Zhaosheng Ding,Huajie Fu,Li Hang,Yu Huang,Huiping Jiang,Huaxin Jiang,Junlian Li,Baoxia Liu,Lijun Pan,Caiyun Shao,Huixia Tan,Qiuwei Tan,Weizhong Wang,Jianping Yang,Meiqin Yi,Qianlu Yin,Hua Yuan,Weixing Zhang,Hong Zhu,Haojun Fei,Liwei Jiang,Wenhong Li,Zhaoer Shen,Xiaomei Sun,Wenjuan Tang,Mingming Wang,Jinlong Wu,Songqing Zhang,Xiaozhong Zhang,Wantong Liu,Wei Cui,Zhaokuan Lei,Yongming Wang,Yongmin Yu,Liucun Song,Tao Wang,Xiaolong Li,Jianrong Luo,Hebin Wang,Weiguo Liu,Fude Zhang,Fang Zhang,Yongfu Wang,Qingna Zhao,Yinbiao Liu,Jianli Li,Liujie Dan,Dakuan Wang,Jiaoxia Yan,Guofu Zhu,Zisen Liu,Zhoulun He,Yongfen Yan,Ping Li,Huailiang Shang,Baichao Heng,Shuli Liu,Zhe Ran,Kun Jiang,Xin Zhu,Haibin Wu,Liling Liang,Jianhui Yuan,Zhigang Wang,Aijing Meng,Jing Wang,Xia Guan,Jiannan Yang,Yan Li,Haixia Liu,Wuying Wang,Xinhao Liu,Fuke Qiao,Xianmin Li,Herong Zhao,Chunyuan Zhu,Yanan Lu,Ning Liu,Yanan Peng,Li Wan,Hairui Chen,Xiaoming Song,Qingtao Lou,Wei Wang,Changshui Liu,Lijuan Zhang,Zhanjiang Zhang,Shijie Yuan,Yongxin Yang,Suqin Chen,Changjie Dong,Jianguo Ran,Weiling Wu,Zhen Li,Hui Zhang,Liujia Duan,Fan Yang,Ying Liu,Kun Wang,Lina Yan,Jiangli Ma,Liuyan Wan,Yanfen Li,Han Wang,Bing Yuan,Ruiling Du,Jie Zhang,Jingge Zhang,Lin Li,Aihua Zhao,Junhong Wei,Ning Zhao,Yonghui Zhu,Wuyi Mao,Qi Luo,Zhongpu Huang,Hongbin Guo,Na Zheng,Weiwei Pan,Meng Qin,Ying Li,Shanshan Xiao,Yun Zhang,Weiying Wu,Jing Li,Liusen Song,Yi Tang,Qineng Yao,Kunyun Yang,Meixiong Kuang,Changlin Bao,Tao Xiao,Yanping Wan,Xiaojie Wan,Binbin Liu,Tieliu Jiang,Xiaoping Zhang,Zhen Tan,Xiaobing Zhang,Zhaoguo Liu,Zhenhua Chen,Yu Wang,Yanyan Yu,Saibo Dai,PeiLei Hu,Chuanfang Zhang,Yanhong Li,Dehua Gong,Liqin Liu,Xiaohong Li,Jie Ling,Xinhua Shan,Z Huo Zhang,Haibing Deng,Zhengbiao Zeng,Honghua Li,Shuiping Zhou,Ying Xu,Can Zhang,Haifeng Chen,Xiaoling Wang,Yao Chen,Sheng Yang,Weiping Peng,Huan Sun,Hui Liao,Xiping Xie,Fang Liang,Cheng Hu,Siwei Hu,Xinyu Liu,Jun Peng,Wenxin Liu,Decheng Liu,Wenbin Liu,Xiangmei Li,Hui Guo,Wen Wang,Yujue He,Bo Wang,Yaping Zhang,Qiaofen Gao,Jianxi Zhao,Weitao Chen,Qing Li,Taojun Mu,Qijun Liang,Jixiu Gu,Ling Ma,Ning An,Junwen Li,Qinhua Yao,Chengzhi Liang,Xiuqun Ge,Yalin Chen,Shumao Luan,Yanhong Sun,Ruifang Yang,Bin Ma,Suiqiang Zhang,Fusheng Liang,Yuan Tian,Hongxia Zhang,Fanqin Yang,Qifeng Lu,Jun Chen,Yan Dong,Shunsheng Zhang,Ziming Jin,Jintao Wang,Jianwei Lan,Zhanjun Zhang,Yumin Wu,Jianlin Shi,Zhaoping Shi,Yan Chen,Jianxin Ding,Xiaofeng An,Jun Yang,Dongdong Ling,Zhenzhou Nie,Chunli Liu,Guangyin Mi,Jun Ma,Jiyun Guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S1473-3099(17)30402-4
Abstract:Background: The management of latent Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection is a new priority action for the WHO End Tuberculosis (TB) Strategy. However, national guidelines on latent tuberculosis infection testing and treatment have not yet been developed in China. Here, we present the results from the 2-year follow-up of a study that aimed to track the development of active disease in individuals with latent tuberculosis infection, identify priority populations for latent infection management, and explore the most suitable latent infection diagnostic approach. Methods: A population-based multicentre prospective study was done in four sites in rural China, between 2013 and 2015. The baseline survey in 2013 measured the prevalence of latent tuberculosis infection using QuantiFERON-TB Gold In-Tube (QFT) and tuberculin skin test (TST) in eligible participants. During the follow-up phase between 2014-15, we assessed individuals who had tuberculosis infection at baseline (QFT-positivity or TST tuberculin reaction size [induration] of ≥10 mm) for the development of active disease through active case finding. Eligible participants included in follow-up survey had a birth date before June 1, 2008 (5 years or older in 2013), and continuous residence at the study site for 6 months or longer in the past year. Participants with current active tuberculosis at baseline survey were excluded. Findings: Between Sept 1, 2013, and Aug 31, 2015, 7505 eligible participants (aged 5 years or older) were included in tuberculosis infection test positive cohorts (4455 were QFT positive, 6404 had TST induration ≥10 mm, and 3354 were positive for both tests) after baseline examination. During the 2-year follow-up period, 84 incident cases of active tuberculosis were diagnosed. Of participants who developed active tuberculosis, 75 were diagnosed with latent infection by QFT, 62 were diagnosed by TST, and 53 were diagnosed by both tests. An incidence rate of 0·87 (95% CI 0·68-1·07) per 100 person-years was observed for individuals who tested positive with QFT, 0·50 (0·38-0·63) per 100 person-years for those who tested positive with TST (p<0·0001), and 0·82 (0·60-1·04) per 100 person-years for those who tested positive with both tests. Male sex and a history of tuberculosis were significantly associated with increased risk of disease development with adjusted hazard ratios of 2·36 (95% CI 1·30-4·30) for male sex and 5·40 (3·34-8·71) for a history of tuberculosis. Interpretation: Our results suggest that high-risk populations in communities in rural China, such as individuals at a high risk of disease reactivation from previous tuberculosis, should be targeted for latent infection screening and treatment with an interferon-γ releasing assay rather than a TST. Funding: National Science and Technology Major Project of China, Program for Changjiang Scholars and Innovative Research Team in University of China, CAMS Innovation Fund for Medical Sciences, and Sanming Project of Medicine in Shenzhen.