Abstract:The present study investigated how Cantonese speakers learning English as a second language (L2) would comprehend English irony and whether their L2 proficiency and use would moderate their irony processing. Thirty Cantonese speakers with differing English proficiency (intermediate vs advanced) were asked to complete an irony comprehension task in which they had to determine if given comments in literal or ironic situations were positive or negative. The irony comprehension task was immediately followed by a stimulated recall session to further explore the participants' thought processes while responding to the irony comprehension items. The results revealed that the participants were faster and more accurate when processing positively-valenced comments (literal praise, ironic criticism), compared to negatively-valenced ones (literal criticism, ironic praise). The findings suggest that learners had greater difficulty identifying ironic praises than ironic criticisms, underscoring the role of valence in second language irony inferencing. The stimulated recall data suggested that the anticipation of irony may accelerate the identification of ironic criticisms. While proficiency facilitated the speed of irony comprehension, the duration of L2 use, especially in speaking, emerged as an important factor in moderating the accuracy of irony comprehension. Understanding irony in a second language (L2) can pose challenges. It goes beyond mere knowledge of vocabulary and grammar; it requires the ability to identify the speaker's intent, which can be hidden or indirect. For instance, when someone says "you are so smart" after a friend does something foolish, they are actually criticizing the friend using a seemingly positive remark. This is referred to as ironic criticism. Conversely, if someone says "you are a lousy cook" after thoroughly enjoying a delicious meal prepared by a friend, they are actually complimenting the friend using a seemingly negative phrase. This is known as ironic praise. In our study, we investigated the extent to which Cantonese speakers comprehend irony in L2 English. Participants were presented with comments and asked to determine whether they were praise or criticism, in both literal and ironic contexts. Subsequently, we examined their thought processes through additional questions. Our findings revealed that learners were quicker and more accurate in identifying comments containing positive words (literal praise and ironic criticism) compared to comments with negative words (literal criticism and ironic praise). Moreover, we observed that an expectation of irony facilitated the understanding of ironic criticism, whereas comprehending ironic praise proved more challenging. Additionally, while English proficiency contributed to faster comprehension of irony, the frequency of English usage, particularly in daily conversations, influenced the accuracy of understanding. Based on our results, we recommend that language teachers promote learners' awareness of understanding ironic praises and encourage the integration of the second language into their daily lives to enhance their ability to understand and appreciate the ironic nuances in L2.

L2 tolerance of pragmatic violations of informativeness

Pragmatic tolerance: Implications for the acquisition of informativeness and implicature

Automatic processing of pragmatic information in the human brain: a mismatch negativity study.

Social Context Modulates Tolerance for Pragmatic Violations in Binary but Not Graded Judgments

Children's Knowledge of Free Choice Inferences

Effects of Semantic and Pragmatic Factors on Preschool Children’s Negation-Triggered Inferences on Possible Alternatives

Second Language Learners’ Competence of and Beliefs About Pragmatic Comprehension: Insights From the Chinese EFL Context

Why some children accept under-informative utterances

Pragmatic failure, epistemic injustice and epistemic vigilance

What could have been said? Alternatives and variability in pragmatic inferences

L2 irony comprehension and the role of L2 proficiency and use

The pragmatics of foreign accents: The social costs and benefits of being a non-native speaker.

Investigating longitudinal pragmatic development of complaints made by Chinese EFL learners

Pragmatic inference of scalar implicature by LLMs

Effects of exposure to L2 input and language proficiency on pragmatic competence during study abroad

Linguistic Dimensions Of Comprehensibility And Perceived Fluency: An Investigation Of Complexity, Accuracy, And Fluency In Second Language Argumentative Speech

Pragmatics learning and teaching in L2 Chinese

Chinese EFL Learners’ Pragmatic Competence and Intercultural Sensitivity

The roles of language proficiency and study abroad in Japanese students’ receptive pragmatic competence