Abstract:Background: Accountable care has changed organizational models adopted by health care organizations profoundly and, consequently, the skill set required for doctor-managers who have become middle managers and must deal with the operational management of their units. Doctor-managers must carry out clinical tasks as well as tasks related to budgeting, goal setting, and performance evaluation. The performance evaluation bias, defined as the misalignment between a ward unit's objective performance (as assessed by technical bodies or agencies) and self-assessed performance by the head of the unit, may have serious consequences for individuals and organizations. Purpose: The aim of this study was to identify determinants of performance appraisal bias based on the mismatch between self-reported and official performance data. Specifically, we analyzed the role played by managerial behavior, training, engagement, and perceived organizational support at the individual level, as well as the particular unit's task diversity, complexity, and predictability. Methodology: We collected primary and secondary data referable to a population of ward unit heads in the Italian National Health Service. A linear regression model predicting performance appraisal bias was employed. Findings: High levels of engagement and perceived organizational support were associated with reduced performance appraisal bias, whereas high levels of predictability and task diversity were associated with increased degree of error. Doctor-managers attending training programs in health care management and ward unit task complexity did not affect bias significantly. Practice implications: Policy makers and hospital managers should provide heads of units with tools that enable them to conduct ongoing monitoring and accurate appraisal of performance. Doctor-manager performance appraisal bias may be diminished by a perception of having support of the organization and direct superiors. Training programs can be revised to incorporate performance appraisal, and good performance may be incentivized with rewards.

How Bias Impacted the Project Manager Decision to Not Terminate a Failing Project

Top Ten Behavioral Biases in Project Management: An Overview

Personality and Project Success: Insights from a Large-Scale Study with Professionals.

Effect of project role, age and gender differences on the formation and revision of project decision judgements

A Dimensional Analysis of Stakeholder Assessment of Project Outcomes

A Correlational Study on Project Management Methodology and Project Success

Project management and its effects on project success: Cross-country and cross-industry comparisons

A Set of Estimation and Decision Preference Experiments for Exploring Risk Assessment Biases in Engineering Students

To Complete or Terminate Smart Manufacturing Projects: a Prospect Theory Perspective

Exploring the Impact of Cultural Values on Project Performance the Effects of Cultural Values, Age and Gender on the Perceived Importance of Project Success/Failure Factors

Cost Overruns and Failure in Project Management: Understanding the Roles of Key Stakeholders in Construction Projects

Contribution of Project Managers’ Capability to Project Ending Performance under Stressful Conditions

Do the Project Manager’s Soft Skills Matter? Impacts of the Project Manager’s Emotional Intelligence, Trustworthiness, and Job Satisfaction on Project Success

What explains managers’ escalating behaviors in a failing NPD project? The impact of managerial perceptions of opportunities and threats in a stage-gate process

Critical thinking, dynamic capabilities, and project performance: empirical evidence in the continuous improvement project domain

Behavior of internal stakeholders in project portfolio management and its impact on success

Role of Organizational Project Management Maturity Factors on Project Success

Impacts of human communication network topology on group optimism bias in Capital Project Planning: a human-subject experiment

Individual and job-related determinants of bias in performance appraisal: The case of middle management in health care organizations

An Empirical Study on Impact of Project Management Constraints in Agile Software Development

Cognitive biases in implementing a performance management system: behavioral strategy for supporting managers’ decision-making processes