Abstract:Income redistribution, which involves transferring income from certain individuals to others, plays a crucial role in human societies. Previous research has indicated that tax-based redistribution can promote cooperation by enhancing incentives for cooperators. In such a tax system, all individuals, irrespective of their income levels, contribute to the tax system, and the tax revenue is subsequently redistributed to everyone. In this study, we relax this assumption by introducing a tax threshold, signifying that only individuals with incomes exceeding the threshold will be subject to taxation. In particular, we employ the spatial public goods game to investigate the influence of tax rates-the percentage of income allocated to tax-and tax thresholds, which determine the income level at which individuals become taxable, on the evolution of cooperation. Our extensive numerical simulations disclose that tax thresholds produce complex outcomes for the evolution of cooperation, depending on tax rates. Notably, at low tax rates (i.e., below 0.41), as the tax threshold increases, discontinuous phase transitions in cooperation performance suggest the presence of multiple intervals of effective tax thresholds that promote peak cooperation levels. Nevertheless, irrespective of the chosen tax rate, once the tax threshold surpasses a critical threshold, the redistribution mechanism fails, causing the collapse of cooperation. Evolutionary snapshots show that self-organized redistribution forms an intermediary layer on the peripheries of cooperative clusters, effectively shielding cooperators from potential defectors. Quantitative analyses shed light on how self-organized redistribution narrows the income gap between cooperators and defectors through precise identification of tax-exempt entities, thereby amplifying the cooperative advantage. Collectively, these findings enhance our comprehension of how income redistribution influences cooperation, highlighting the pivotal role of tax thresholds.

Public good provision and progressive income taxation in a spatial economy

Taxing the Second Nature ∗

Does Technological Progress Magnify Regional Disparities?

Tax thresholds yield multiple optimal cooperation levels in the spatial public goods game

Tax Competition, Region Game and Their Efficiency of Growth

Optimal Central Redistribution with Decentralized Redistribution

Local Tax Competition and Spatial Mobility of Labor with Heterogeneous Preferences in China:Evidence from Metropolitan Areas of Beijing,Tianjin and Hebei

Production externalities and dispersion process in a multi-region economy

Private production, collective consumption, and regional population structure: the interactions between public and private good provision as determinants of community composition

Public infrastructure provision in the presence of terms‐of‐trade effects and tax competition

Effects of income redistribution on the evolution of cooperation in spatial public goods games

Spatial Equilibria: The Case of Two Regions

Redistribution Through Tax Relief

Profit Shifting Frictions and the Geography of Multinational Activity

Nash equilibria in models of fiscal competition with unemployment

Heterogeneity, Transfer Progressivity, and Business Cycles

Taxation and Migration: Evidence and Policy Implications

The political economy of inequality, mobility and redistribution

Redistribution spurs growth by using a portfolio effect on human capital

"Public goods, labor supply and benefit taxation"

Progressive consumption tax reforms