Black Mobilization After Emancipation: Evidence from Reconstruction and the Great Migration

K. Chay,Kaivan Munshi

Abstract:We present evidence that African-Americans in the South responded collectively to the political and economic opportunities that arose after the Civil War, but only in areas where the organization of production permitted strong social ties to emerge. Specifically, we examine political participation during and just after Reconstruction (1870-1890) and the movement to northern cities during the Great Migration (19161930). In contrast to most empirical work on social networks and social capital, we analyze the process of group formation from its inception (Emancipation) and utilize a plausibly exogenous source of variation in social cohesion among potential members, measured by the share of land allocated to labor-intensive plantation crops – the plantation share – in each southern county. Our theoretical model shows that cooperation cannot be supported at plantation shares (social cohesion) below a threshold but that the size of the collaborating group is monotonically increasing in plantation share above that threshold. The patterns of political participation and migration across counties that we uncover are consistent with the theory there is no association with plantation share up to a threshold at which a steep monotonic relationship begins. This finding is robust to rigorous testing, and these tests show that competing hypotheses do not exhibit similar nonlinear patterns. Our results indicate that blacks from southern counties with high plantation shares accounted for a disproportionate share of the migrants to the North and that these migrants (who would have moved as a group) were concentrated at a limited number of destinations, with potentially long-term implications for the evolution of African-American communities across northern cities.