Can normal inflammatory markers rule out acute appendicitis? The reliability of biochemical investigations in diagnosis
Jason J. Y. Kim,Benjamin H. Dobson,Cedric L. H. Ng,Da Wei Thong,Thomas Arthur,David Parker,QUEST Collaboration,Tahmina Anwari,Leigh Archer,Michael Auld,Dominic Bagguley,Jubin Bhatt,Christopher Bierton,Sarah Bormann,Kimberley Bradshaw,Rosie Callahan,Gian Capati,Daniel Cattanach,Debbie Chai,Matthew Cozier,Fermina Daza,Olivia Della Martina,Marilla Dickfos,Catriona Duncan,Laura Edward,Kristen Elstner,Luke Franceschini,Emma Fuller,Roderick Gavey,Hariette Goldman,Hobia Gole,Elizabeth Harrison,Matthew Honore,Ian Hughes,Yang Hwang,Matthew Jacob,Anshini Jain,Stephanie Jones,Anita Kothapalli,Michael Kwok,Bruce Lavarack,Lisa Lee,David Liu,James Lonie,Nicholas Low,David Mackrill,Guy Maddern,Julia McFarlane,Dinusha Metcalfe,Xavier Moar,Brendon Morden,Hajir Nabi,Eu Nice Neo,Daniel Ng Ying Kin,Eavan O'Brien,Peter O'Donohue,Sarah Paget,Keith Potent,Harald Puhalla,Roshan Ramachandran,Muhammad Rosley,Michael Schachtel,Amy Schmidt,Kendall Sharpe,Arjun Shivananda,Douglas Stupart,Shayan Ta'I,Mary Theophilus,Phill Toonsen,Cristian Udovicich,Bianca Van Der Nest,Anna Walch,Daniel Walker,Enoch Wong,Zee Hame Wong,Omar Zubair,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ans.15559
IF: 1.7
2019-11-12
ANZ Journal of Surgery
Abstract:BackgroundAcute appendicitis is a common general surgical condition where diagnosis is predominantly clinical, with the aid of adjunct investigations. This study reviews the relationship between normal and elevated biochemical inflammatory markers, duration of symptoms and proven appendicitis. MethodsA multicentre prospective observational study was performed across 27 centres and included a total of 949 patients with clinical suspicion of appendicitis, who had both white cell count (WCC) and C‐reactive protein (CRP) recorded and underwent appendicectomy. ResultsA total of 90.4% of patients with raised WCC and CRP had appendicitis with a positive predictive value (PPV) of 0.9 and negative predictive value (NPV) of 0.4. Sensitivity and specificity of elevated WCC (sensitivity 66.5%, specificity 66.0%) and elevated CRP (sensitivity 77.3%, specificity 52.0%) lie within ranges identified by previous studies. A total of 39.8% of patients with normal CRP and WCC had appendicitis. Sensitivity and PPV for patients with elevated inflammatory markers were high until 48 h of symptoms (sensitivity 94%, PPV 0.87). NPV was elevated after 24 h (NPV 0.65 in patients with 24–48 h of symptoms, and 0.61 after 48 h), whilst those with symptoms less than 24 h had a lower NPV of 0.52. ConclusionWhilst elevated inflammatory markers are a helpful aid in the diagnosis of appendicitis, they should not be relied on by themselves. Nor can normal inflammatory markers be used to exclude appendicitis, even in those with prolonged duration of symptoms. The diagnosis of appendicitis should be guided by a combination of clinical judgement with the assistance of inflammatory markers.
surgery