A Cross-Sectional Study of Clinical Trials on Radiotherapy Combined with Immunotherapy
M. Yuan,Z. Hui,Y. Men,J. Kang,X. Sun,M. Zhao,Y. Bao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrobp.2019.06.1429
2019-01-01
Abstract:Although remarkable advances have been made in Immuno-Oncology (IO) therapy, especially in immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI), the overall response rate is limited. Radiotherapy (RT) may generate synergistic anti-tumor effects when combined with IO therapy. The clinical trials of combined RT and IO therapy have increased rapidly during the past few years. This study is to comprehensively summarize and analyze these clinical trials and provide a view of the latest landscape of combination strategies. Trials registered on the electronic (https://clinicaltrials.gov) Jan. 2009 and Jan. 2019 were searched using "Radiotherapy AND Immunotherapy | Recruiting, Not yet recruiting, Active, not recruiting, Completed, Enrolling by invitation Studies | Interventional Studies | Cancer". Statistical analysis software was used to analyze the data. Totally 397 clinical trials of RT and IO combination therapy were recorded, including 290 active. Geographically, most of the trials are carried out in the USA (n=262, 66.0%). China has the fastest increase from the last year. From timeline, the past 3 years has seen a soaring number of 213 clinical trials, with 92 new trials started in 2018 alone. From 328 trials which indicated the type of tumor, 71 trials are in lung cancer (21.6%), followed by lymphoma (n=42, 12.8%) and melanoma (n=36, 11.0%). As for combination strategies, trials of tumor vaccine combined with RT were the most frequent before 2018. However, at present, ICI has exceeded tumor vaccine in the combination with RT and makes up the absolute most (n=275, 69.3%). In lung cancer, lymphoma and melanoma, ICI is the most common choice for combination (70.0%, 69.2% and 47.4%, respectively), while in prostate cancer and breast cancer, RT combined with tumor vaccine is still more often (71.4% and 48.8%, respectively). On the whole, most of the trials are in phase I/II (75%). Although most trials are set for advanced or metastatic cancers (n=172, 43.3%), there are a few exploring the safety and effectiveness of combination therapy for early stage cancers or as neo-adjuvant therapy (n=27, 6.8%). Trials of ICI combined with RT have the fastest growing, although most are in phase I/II. Further studies are needed to explore the more detailed rational combination strategies, such as the timing, fractionation, and dose of RT, and the optimized IO agent.