Abstract:We consider the dynamic behavior of several variants of the Network Creation Game, introduced by Fabrikant et al. [PODC'03]. Equilibrium networks in these models have desirable properties like low social cost and small diameter, which makes them attractive for the decentralized creation of overlay-networks. Unfortunately, due to the non-constructiveness of the Nash equilibrium, no distributed algorithm for finding such networks is known. We treat these games as sequential-move games and analyze whether (uncoordinated) selfish play eventually converges to an equilibrium state. Thus, we shed light on one of the most natural algorithms for this problem: distributed local search, where in each step some agent performs a myopic selfish improving move. We show that fast convergence is guaranteed for all versions of Swap Games, introduced by Alon et al. [SPAA'10], if the initial network is a tree, and show that this process can be sped up to an almost optimal number of moves. For non-tree networks we show the surprising result that even one non-tree edge suffices to destroy the convergence guarantee and no move policy can enforce convergence. This answers an open problem from Ehsani et al. [SPAA'11] in the negative. We extend our negative results to the well-studied original version and prove that there is no convergence guarantee -- even if all agents play optimally. Furthermore, we show the quite surprising result that employing cost-sharing yields even worse dynamic behavior. Finally, we contrast our mostly negative theoretical results by a careful empirical study. Our simulations indicate two positive facts: (1) The non-convergent behavior seems to be confined to a small set of pathological instances and is unlikely to show up in practice. (2) In all our simulations we observed a remarkably fast convergence towards a stable network in O(n) steps, where n is the number of agents.

Local Network Effects and Complex Network Structure

Estimating Local Interactions Among Many Agents Who Observe Their Neighbors

Games on Endogenous Networks

Network Effects on Strategic Interactions: A Laboratory Approach

Local farsightedness in network formation

Social Interactions in Large Networks: A Game Theoretic Approach

Choosing Products in Social Networks

Stable and efficient networks with neighborhood‐influenced externalities

The Hitchhiker's Guide to Affiliation Networks: A Game-Theoretic Approach

Temporal Network Creation Games: The Impact of Non-Locality and Terminals

Distributed Nash equilibrium seeking in noncooperative game with partial decision information of neighbors

Expectations, Networks, and Conventions

On Dynamics in Selfish Network Creation

Games Under Network Uncertainty

Social Connectedness and Local Contagion

Social network markets: the influence of network structure when consumers face decisions over many similar choices

Networks with nonordered partitioning of players: stability and efficiency with neighborhood-influenced cost topology

Two-Step Estimation of a Strategic Network Formation Model with Clustering

Competitive Contagion in Networks

Nash Equilibria on (Un)Stable Networks

Network Creation with Homophilic Agents