Learning Effective Instructional Strategies in a Workshop Context: Lessons about Conceptual Change from Chinese English Teachers
Jian Wang,Emily Lin,Elizabeth Spalding
2008-01-01
Abstract:Changing teachers’ beliefs about knowledge, learning, and teaching is assumed to be important in helping them develop effective teaching strategies encouraged by educational reformers (DarlingHammond, 1995; Kennedy, 1991b). This assumption is based on two lines of research in Western teacher education literature. First, although demonstrated through various teacher classroom behaviors (Brophy, 1989), effective teaching is largely shaped by the kinds of dispositions and thoughts that teachers hold for their teaching (Clark & Lampert, 1986; Richardson, 1996). As such, learning to teach using effective teaching strategies necessitates the initial development of relevant dispositions and ideas. Second, the dispositions and ideas underlying teaching strategies advocated in teaching reforms are often different from prevailing teaching practices (Feiman-Nemser, 2001; Wang & Odell, 2002). Thus, learning to use new teaching strategies for many teachers means an inadvertent process of conceptual change about learning and teaching rather than a direct formation of certain teaching behaviors. However, changing teachers’ existing conceptions towards new ways of teaching in short and intense workshops situations have shown to be difficult, if not impossible, in U.S. school contexts (McDiarmid, 1991; Richardson, 1996; Wideen, Mayer-Smith, & Moon, 1998). Drawing on data using surveys, daily reflections, and written documents from a group of elementary and secondary Chinese English teachers, this study attempts to describe the factors that influence and limit their conceptual change and acquisition of effective teaching strategies in a workshop context. Using this as a base, the study further explores the strengths and limitations of popular theories and assumptions in explaining teachers’ conceptual change.