PERSONALITY PATTERNS IN PATIENTS WITH AFFECTIVE DISORDERS

C. Perris
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0447.1971.tb02136.x
1971-03-01
Abstract:In a previous report (Perris 1966) i t was shown that bipolar (manicdepressive) and unipolar depressive psychotics have different personality traits. The series comprised 108 patients (50 bipolar and 58 unipolar) who were studied with an abridged version of the Nyman-Marke Temperament Scale (NMTS: Nyman & Marke 1958) during a symptomfree interval. Bipolar patients showed higher scores in the ”substability” (syntony) variable, the unipolar ones, on the other hand, in the ”subvalidity” (psychasthenia) variable; the difference was independent of sex and age. Global personality evaluation by Angst (1966) gave results in line with the above-mentioned study and agrees, by and large, with results presented by Leonhard et al. (1962, 1963). In a recent careful investigation von Zerssen et al. (1968) came to the conclusion that unipolar patients frequently show psychasthenic and anancastic traits. Metcalfe (1968) suggested a tendency to repetitive worrying as well as a rigid attitude in recovered depressive patients; this also agrees with the opinion of Kielholz (1959) as regards patients classified as suffering from ”involutional melancholy”. There are a few studies concerned with the Maudsley Personality Inventory (MPI: Eysenck 1959) and depressive disorders (Astroim & Olander 1960, Wretmark et al. 1961, 1970, Coppen & Metcalfe 1965, Metcalfe 1968, Thelma et al. 1969, Kerr et al. 1970). Most of these studies have been concerned more with the influence of a depressive disorder on MPI scores than with possible differences between different groups of depressed patients. Changes in MPI scores were reported by all investigators in patients who improved or recovered. E-scores increased and N-scores decreased from the phase of illness to that of recovery both in patients diagnosed as ”endogenous” and ”reactive”. Astrom & Olander (1960) found on discharge higher E-scores in ”endogenous” than in ”reactive” patients, but no difference in N-scores. Kerr et al. (1970) among
What problem does this paper attempt to address?