Abstract:Background/Context Federal policy, as codified in Race to the Top (RTT) funding guidelines, outlines four types of intervention: turnaround, restart, closure, and transformation. RTT has embraced a technocratic paradigm for school reform that frames choice less as the opportunity for the public to deliberate about what it wants from its schools and more in terms of the freedom of individual families to choose, as customers, from a diverse array of school options. This market-based system has eroded substantive opportunities for parents and students to participate in decisions about their schools. Although scholars have developed compelling arguments about the need to involve parents and teachers in a more deliberative and democratic approach to intervening in low-performing schools, there is little scholarship focused on the role of young people in school intervention processes. Purpose There is widespread agreement among progressive critics that RTT interventions are not sufficiently democratic. More work is needed to develop participatory approaches. In some cases this may require departing from a strict “evidence-based” framework and imagining new alternatives consistent with values of social justice and educational equity. It also requires expanding existing treatments of deliberative democracy theory to include young people. Research Design & Findings: This article makes a conceptual argument rooted in theory, empirical literature, and practical experience in schools. After explaining theories of participatory democracy, youth–adult partnerships, and thirdspace, we propose five practices that should guide a deliberative, participatory approach to public decision-making about schools. These are: border-crossing facilitation, participatory research, multilingual and multicultural discourse practices, authentic decision-making, and joint work and distributed expertise. Conclusions/Recommendations The current school turnaround paradigm, embodied by closures, conversion to charters, and teacher reassignments, has left a great deal of collateral damage in its wake. Teachers work under threat of firing. We propose an alternative approach to improve struggling public neighborhood schools—not just another option in a menu of turnaround strategies, but an alternative frame and set of practices that expands the conversation about intervention. This approach encourages deliberation and communication among diverse networks of students, teachers, and families.

Restorative Schools: A Consultation Case Study for Moving from Theory to Practice

Restorative Justice and School-wide Transformation: Identifying Drivers of Implementation and System Change

Restorative Practices for Empowerment: A Social Work Lens

Use of Restorative Justice and Restorative Practices at School: A Systematic Literature Review

Effectiveness of Restorative Justice in US K-12 Schools: a Review of Quantitative Research

Restorative justice informed criminal justice social work and probation services

Seeking justice rooted in truth, reconciliation and forgiveness

Examining the effectiveness of a restorative justice program for various types of juvenile offenders

Cultivating healing by implementing restorative practices for youth: Protocol for a cluster randomized trial

Insights from Developing and Implementing a Novel School Community Collaborative Model to Promote School Safety

The Impact of Restorative Practices on the Use of Out-of-School Suspensions: Results from a Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial

Research on the Impact of Restorative Justice Implementation on the Social Reintegration of Offenders and the Reduction of Recidivism Rates

Transforming Communities: Restorative Justice as a Community Building Strategy

Restorative Just Culture: An Exploration of the Enabling Conditions for Successful Implementation

Evaluation of the whole school restorative practices project: One-year impact on discipline incidents

Preventing Bullying and Improving School Climate Through Integrating Youth Participatory Action Research Into School-wide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports: An Illustration Using a Multiple Case Study Approach

Participatory Democracy and Struggling Schools: Making Space for Youth in School Turnarounds

The Transformative Potential of Restorative Justice: What the Mainstream Can Learn from the Margins

Addressing individual and community needs in the aftermath of campus sexual misconduct: restorative justice as a way forward in the re-entry process

Understanding school-based policing: recommendations for improving School Resource Officer programs and promoting safer schools

A case study of participatory action research in a public new England middle school: empowerment, constraints and challenges