Abstract:Moving in groups offers animals protection against predation. When under attack, grouped individuals often turn collectively to evade a predator, which sometimes makes them rapidly change their relative positions in the group. In bird flocks in particular, the quick reshuffling of flock members confuses the predator, challenging its targeting of a single individual. This confusion is considered to be greater when the internal structure of the group changes faster (i.e. the 'diffusion' of the group is higher). Diffusion may increase when individual birds turn collectively with equal radii (same angular velocity) but not when individuals keep their paths parallel (by adjusting their speed). However, how diffusion depends on individual behaviour is not well known. When under attack, grouping individuals change the way they interact with each other, referred to as 'alarmed coordination' (e.g., increase their reaction frequency or their cohesion tendency), but the effect of such changes on collective turning is unknown. Here, we aimed to gain an understanding of the dynamics of collective turning in bird flocks. First, to investigate the relation between alarmed coordination and flock diffusion, we developed an agent-based model of bird flocks. Second, to test how diffusion relates to collective turns with equal-radii and parallel-paths, we developed a metric of the deviation from these two types. Third, we studied collective turning under predation empirically, by analysing the GPS trajectories of pigeons in small flocks pursued by a RobotFalcon. As a measure of diffusion, we used the instability of neighbours: the rate with which the closest neighbours of a flock member are changing. In our simulations, we showed that this instability increases with group size, reaction frequency, topological range, and cohesion tendency and that the relation between instability of neighbours and the deviation from the two turning types depends in often counter-intuitive ways on these coordination specifics. Empirically, we showed that pigeons turn collectively with less diffusion than starlings and that their collective turns are in between those with equal-radii and parallel-paths. Overall, our work provides a framework for studying collective turning across species.

Pigeons trade efficiency for stability in response to level of challenge during confined flight

Rules to fly by: pigeons navigating horizontal obstacles limit steering by selecting gaps most aligned to their flight direction

Fine-scale changes in speed and altitude suggest protean movements in homing pigeon flights

Turbulence causes kinematic and behavioural adjustments in a flapping flier

Robustness of flight leadership relations in pigeons

Route-dependent Switch Between Hierarchical and Egalitarian Strategies in Pigeon Flocks

Bird Maneuvering Flight: Blurred Bodies, Clear Heads

Pigeons produce aerodynamic torques through changes in wing trajectory during low speed aerial turns

Optimization of avian perching manoeuvres

Trade-offs between stability and manoeuvrability in bird flight

Diffusion during collective turns in bird flocks under predation

Exploring boundary conditions of the single-code/default strategy in pigeons

Intermittence and Connectivity of Interactions in Pigeon Flock Flights

Hungry pigeons prefer sooner rare food over later likely food or faster information

Birds can transition between stable and unstable states via wing morphing

Understanding the agility of running birds: Sensorimotor and mechanical factors in avian bipedal locomotion

Coordinating directional switches in pigeon flocks: the role of nonlinear interactions

Flying fast improves aerodynamic economy of heavier birds

Hierarchical group dynamics in pigeon flocks

Brightness cues affect gap negotiation behaviours in zebra finches flying between perches

Naïve individuals promote collective exploration in homing pigeons