Tolerance allocation: Balancing quality, cost, and waste through production rate optimization

Yue Wang,Aihua Huang,Carolyn A. Quigley,Lei Li,John W. Sutherland

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124837

IF: 11.1

2021-02-01

Journal of Cleaner Production

Abstract:Dimensional tolerance allocation is a very important and difficult task that traditionally seeks to balance cost/productivity and quality. Common tolerance allocation models have two shortcomings: i) they are overly reliant on models focused on minimizing cost and tend to ignore waste, and ii) they fail to connect to the root cause of many quality issues: process variation. This paper proposes a tolerance allocation model that addresses these shortcomings. The proposed model considers both product design (tolerance selection) and operation planning (or production rate selection). Relations among production rate, production cost, processing precision, and waste are considered. A gradient-based optimization method is proposed to minimize the cost and waste. A clutch assembly case study is analyzed to evaluate the method. Monte Carlo simulations are employed to validate the accuracy of the proposed cost model. The proposed method is compared with a heuristic method from the literature. The proposed method produced more satisfactory products at a lower cost while producing less waste. For the case study, it is found that when the precision of a process is high, it is not necessary from an economic standpoint to inspect the quality of individual components. For poor precision processes, inspecting the quality of individual components is the preferred approach from a cost/throughput standpoint.

environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology,engineering, environmental

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of how to balance quality, cost, and waste through productivity optimization during the manufacturing process. Specifically, traditional tolerance allocation models primarily focus on minimizing cost while neglecting waste and failing to consider process variability as the root cause of many quality issues. Therefore, the paper proposes a new tolerance allocation model that aims to consider both product design (tolerance selection) and operational planning (productivity selection) simultaneously, and to minimize cost and waste through productivity optimization. The study analyzes a clutch assembly case and uses Monte Carlo simulation to verify the accuracy of the cost model. The results show that the proposed method reduces waste while lowering costs. For high-precision processes, it is not economically necessary to inspect the quality of individual components; however, for low-precision processes, it is recommended to inspect the quality of individual components to optimize cost and production efficiency.