Abstract:Active learning in college classes and participation in the workforce frequently hinge on small group work. However, group dynamics vary, ranging from equitable collaboration to dysfunctional groups dominated by one individual. To explore how group dynamics impact student learning, we asked students in a large-enrollment university biology class to self-report their experience during in-class group work. Specifically, we asked students whether there was a friend in their group, whether they were comfortable in their group, and whether someone dominated their group. Surveys were administered after students participated in two different types of intentionally constructed group activities: 1) a loosely-structured activity wherein students worked together for an entire class period (termed the 'single-group' activity), or 2) a highly-structured 'jigsaw' activity wherein students first independently mastered different subtopics, then formed new groups to peer-teach their respective subtopics. We measured content mastery by the change in score on identical pre-/post-tests. We then investigated whether activity type or student demographics predicted the likelihood of reporting working with a dominator, being comfortable in their group, or working with a friend. We found that students who more strongly agreed that they worked with a dominator were 17.8% less likely to answer an additional question correct on the 8-question post-test. Similarly, when students were comfortable in their group, content mastery increased by 27.5%. Working with a friend was the single biggest predictor of student comfort, although working with a friend did not impact performance. Finally, we found that students were 67% less likely to agree that someone dominated their group during the jigsaw activities than during the single group activities. We conclude that group activities that rely on positive interdependence, and include turn-taking and have explicit prompts for students to explain their reasoning, such as our jigsaw, can help reduce the negative impact of inequitable groups.

The nine dynamics of mutual aid in social work group education: reflections and lessons from a low residency cohort model project

Class participation as a pedagogical tool in social work education

Social workers helping each other during the COVID-19 pandemic: Online mutual support groups

Cacophony, polyphony or fugue: Exploring sociocultural concepts with social work students

Instilling the Soul of Group Work in Social Work Education

How was mutual aid being conceptualized during its proliferation in the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic? a critical phenomenological analysis

Community Care as a Way of Life: Understanding and Evaluating the Impacts of Mutual Aid on Quality of Life and Ways to Implement this Framework in the US

Isolation in the midst of a pandemic: social work students rapidly respond to community and field work needs

Theory is Not Enough! Experiential and Project-Based Approaches to Teaching International Social Work

In the Nest: Case Studies from the School-Based Mental Health Collaboration

Exploring Knowledge through Peer Tutoring in a Transitional Learning Community: An Alternative Way of Teaching Counseling Skills to Students in Social Work Education

Socialization in Higher Education: When Experiencing Shared Realities Can Benefit Students

Storied reflections: Development of a longitudinal interdisciplinary curriculum to improve patient-provider communication

Student perception of group dynamics predicts individual performance: Comfort and equity matter

Health and illness in context: a pragmatic, interdisciplinary approach to teaching and learning applied public health within an urban safety net system

Preparing Social Work Students for International Interdisciplinary Practice: A Teaching Model and Its Impact on Self-Efficacy

Studying community development: a network analytical approach

The Dynamics of Community Engagement in Distance Education: A Sociological Analysis Based on Online Learning Platforms

Student Experiences Engaging in Interdisciplinary Research Collaborations: A Case Study for Social Work Education

The university/community partnership: transdisciplinary course development

Collective and Creative Learning to Enhance Interlibrary Loan