Abstract:Purpose Social media platforms are a pervasive technology that continues to define the modern world. While social media has brought many benefits to society in terms of connection and content sharing, numerous concerns remain for the governance of social media platforms going forward, including (but not limited to) the spread of misinformation, hate speech and online surveillance. However, the voice of citizens and other non-experts is often missing from such conversations in information systems literature, which has led to an alleged gap between research and the everyday life of citizens. Design/methodology/approach The authors address this gap by presenting findings from 16 h of online dialog with 25 citizens on social media platform governance. The online dialog was undertaken as part of a worldwide consultation project called "We, the internet", which sought to provide citizens with a voice on a range of topics such as "Digitalization and Me," "My Data, Your Data, Our Data" and "A Strong Digital Public Sphere." Five phases of thematic analysis were undertaken by the authors to code the corpus of qualitative data. Findings Drawing on the Theory of Communicative Action, the authors discuss three dialogical processes critical to citizen discourse: lifeworld reasoning, rationalization and moral action. The findings point toward citizens' perspectives of current and future issues associated with social media platform governance, including concerns around the multiplicity of digital identities, consent for vulnerable groups and transparency in content moderation. The findings also reveal citizens' rationalization of the dilemmas faced in addressing these issues going forward, including tensions such as digital accountability vs data privacy, protection vs inclusion and algorithmic censorship vs free speech. Originality/value Based on outcomes from this dialogical process, moral actions in the form of policy recommendations are proposed by citizens and for citizens. The authors find that tackling these dark sides of digitalization is something too important to be left to "Big Tech" and equally requires an understanding of citizens' perspectives to ensure an informed and positive imprint for change.

Whose Site Are We On? The Emerging Politics of Digital Journalism Studies

Power to the People? Conceptualising Audience Agency for the Digital Journalism Era

Cultures of Digital Architectures: Power and Positionalities in the Backend of Online Journalism Production

Whose Side are Ethics Codes On? Power, Responsibility and the Social Good

The dark side of digitalization and social media platform governance: a citizen engagement study

Researching Social Media as if the Social Mattered

Editorial: Reconceptualizing public sphere(s) in the digital age? On the role and future of public sphere theory

Civility, Subversion and Technocratic Class Consciousness: Reconstituting Truth in the Journalistic Field

Beyond journalism: Theorizing the transformation of journalism

‘The politics of things’: digital media, urban space, and the materiality of publics

A Balance of Uncertainties: Renewing Attention to the Socialized Spaces Shaping Digital Journalism Studies

Taming the ‘trolls’: How journalists negotiate the boundaries of journalism and online comments

Social Media, Democracy and Public Service Media

Journalism beyond democracy: A new look into journalistic roles in political and everyday life

The Struggle for News Value in the Digital Era

Audiences in an Age of Datafication: Critical Questions for Media Research

The Journalistic Field in the Platform Economy: The New York Times and the Inverted Pyramid

Envisioning a More Inclusive Future for Digital Journalism: A Diversity Audit of Journalism Studies (2013–2021)

Challenges and Opportunities for the Future of Media and Mass Communication Theory and Research: Positionality, Integrative Research, and Public Scholarship

Changing Public Opinion and Politics in the Social Media Era

Euphoria, disillusionment and fear: Twenty-five years of digital journalism (research)