Abstract:The presence, magnitude, and significance of sex differences in the human brain are hotly debated topics in the scientific community and popular media. This debate is largely fueled by studies containing strong, opposing conclusions: either little to no evidence exists for sex differences in human neuroanatomy, or there are small-to-moderate differences in the size of certain brain regions that are highly reproducible across cohorts (even after controlling for sex differences in average brain size). Our Commentary uses the specific comparison between two recent large-scale studies that adopt these opposing views—namely the review by Eliot and colleagues (2021) and the direct analysis of ~ 40k brains by Williams and colleagues (2021)—in an effort to clarify this controversy and provide a framework for conducting this research. First, we review observations that motivate research on sex differences in human neuroanatomy, including potential causes (evolutionary, genetic, and environmental) and effects (epidemiological and clinical evidence for sex-biased brain disorders). We also summarize methodological and empirical support for using structural MRI to investigate such patterns. Next, we outline how researchers focused on sex differences can better specify their study design (e.g., how sex was defined, if and how brain size was adjusted for) and results (by e.g., distinguishing sexual dimorphisms from sex differences). We then compare the different approaches available for studying sex differences across a large number of individuals: direct analysis, meta-analysis, and review. We stress that reviews do not account for methodological differences across studies, and that this variation explains many of the apparent inconsistencies reported throughout recent reviews (including the work by Eliot and colleagues). For instance, we show that amygdala volume is consistently reported as male-biased in studies with sufficient sample sizes and appropriate methods for brain size correction. In fact, comparing the results from multiple large direct analyses highlights small, highly reproducible sex differences in the volume of many brain regions (controlling for brain size). Finally, we describe best practices for the presentation and interpretation of these findings. Care in interpretation is important for all domains of science, but especially so for research on sex differences in the human brain, given the existence of broad societal gender-biases and a history of biological data being used justify sexist ideas. As such, we urge researchers to discuss their results from simultaneously scientific and anti-sexist viewpoints.

A Cross-Species Neuroimaging Study of Sex Chromosome Dosage Effects on Human and Mouse Brain Anatomy

Sexual dimorphic regulation of stress response: Effect of gonadectomy in the rat

Comparative neuroimaging of sex differences in human and mouse brain anatomy

A model system for study of sex chromosome effects on sexually dimorphic neural and behavioral traits

Sex-biased Effects on Hippocampal Circuit Development by Perinatal SERT Expression in CA3 Pyramidal Neurons.

Influence of gonadal and chromosomal sex on the brain transcriptome in a mouse species with natural sex reversal

Integrative structural, functional, and transcriptomic analyses of sex-biased brain organization in humans

A cross-species analysis of neuroanatomical covariance sex difference in humans and mice

Sex chromosomes and hormones independently influence healthy brain development but act similarly after cranial radiation

Using Organoids to Model Sex Differences in the Human Brain

Sex-biased gene and microRNA expression in the developing mouse brain is associated with neurodevelopmental functions and neurological phenotypes

Sex differences in sex chromosome gene expression in mouse brain

Profiling of Sexually Dimorphic Genes in Neural Cells to Identify Eif2s3y, Whose Overexpression Causes Autism-Like Behaviors in Male Mice

The variegation of human brain vulnerability to rare genetic disorders and convergence with behaviorally defined disorders

Chromosomal and gonadal sex have differing effects on social motivation in mice

X-chromosome influences on neuroanatomical variation in humans

X chromosome dosage and the genetic impact across human tissues

Sex differences in the human brain: a roadmap for more careful analysis and interpretation of a biological reality

Effect of Age on Sexually Dimorphic Expression of X‐linked Genes in the Developing Mouse Cortex and Hippocampus

Identification of sexually dimorphic genes in the neonatal mouse cortex and hippocampus

Spatially-resolved molecular sex differences at single cell resolution in the adult human hypothalamus