Abstract:Sensitive caregiving behavior, which involves the ability to notice, interpret, and quickly respond to a child's signals of need and/or interest, is a central determinant of secure child–caregiver attachment. Yet, significant heterogeneity in effect sizes exists across the literature, and sources of heterogeneity have yet to be explained. For all child–caregiver dyads, there was a significant and positive pooled association between caregiver sensitivity and parent–child attachment ( r = .25, 95% CI [.22, .28], k = 174, 230 effect sizes, N = 22,914). We also found a positive association between maternal sensitivity and child attachment security ( r = .26, 95% CI [.22, .29], k = 159, 202 effect sizes, N = 21,483), which was equivalent in magnitude to paternal sensitivity and child attachment security ( r = .21, 95% CI [.14, 27], k = 22, 23 effect sizes, N = 1,626). Maternal sensitivity was also negatively associated with all three classifications of insecure attachment (avoidant: k = 43, r = −.24 [−.34, −.13]; resistant: k = 43, r = −.12 [−.19, −.06]; disorganized: k = 24, r = −.19 [−.27, −.11]). For maternal sensitivity, associations were larger in studies that used the Attachment Q-Sort (vs. the Strange Situation), used the Maternal Behavior Q-Sort (vs. Ainsworth or Emotional Availability Scales), had strong (vs. poor) interrater measurement reliability, had a longer observation of sensitivity, and had less time elapse between assessments. For paternal sensitivity, associations were larger in older (vs. younger) fathers and children. These findings confirm the importance of both maternal and paternal sensitivity for the development of child attachment security and add understanding of the methodological and substantive factors that allow this effect to be observed. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved)

Child–father and child–mother attachment relationships in naturalistic settings

Maternal and paternal sensitivity: Key determinants of child attachment security examined through meta-analysis.

Positive aspects of fathering and mothering, and children's attachment in kindergarten

The Father-Child Activation Relationship, Sex Differences, and Attachment Disorganization in Toddlerhood

Infant and preschool attachment, continuity and relationship to caregiving sensitivity: findings from a new population-based Australian cohort

Predicting infant–father attachment: the role of pre- and postnatal triadic family alliance and paternal testosterone levels

Context matters: Maternal and paternal sensitivity to infants in four settings.

Maternal sensitivity and child attachment security in a low SES Peruvian sample: longitudinal relationships

Assessing both safe haven and secure base support in parent–child relationships

Child Care Caregiver Sensitivity and Attachment

Patterns of risk and trajectories of preschool problem behaviors: a person-oriented analysis of attachment in context

Parenting in context: Marital adjustment, parent affect, and child temperament in complex families.

The significance of early parent-child attachment for emerging regulation: A longitudinal investigation of processes and mechanisms from toddler age to preadolescence.

Maternal Depressive Symptoms and Preschoolers’ Helping, Sharing, and Comforting: The Moderating Role of Child Attachment

Infant and parent factors associated with early maternal sensitivity: a caregiver-attachment systems approach

Fathers and mothers at play with their 2- and 3-year-olds: contributions to language and cognitive development.

Secure attachment in infancy predicts context-dependent emotion expression in middle childhood.

Fathers' contributions to attachment in adolescence and adulthood: the moderating role of race, gender, income, and residential status

Paternal and maternal warmth and the development of prosociality among preschoolers.

Paternal and Maternal Depressive Symptoms and Sensitivity: Links with Trajectories of Socioemotional Problems in Toddlerhood

Mothers' and fathers' working models of childhood attachment relationships, parenting styles, and child behavior