Abstract:The emergence of a variety of Machine Learning (ML) approaches for travel mode choice prediction poses an interesting question to transport modellers: which models should be used for which applications? The answer to this question goes beyond simple predictive performance, and is instead a balance of many factors, including behavioural interpretability and explainability, computational complexity, and data efficiency. There is a growing body of research which attempts to compare the predictive performance of different ML classifiers with classical random utility models. However, existing studies typically analyse only the disaggregate predictive performance, ignoring other aspects affecting model choice. Furthermore, many studies are affected by technical limitations, such as the use of inappropriate validation schemes, incorrect sampling for hierarchical data, lack of external validation, and the exclusive use of discrete metrics. We address these limitations by conducting a systematic comparison of different modelling approaches, across multiple modelling problems, in terms of the key factors likely to affect model choice (out-of-sample predictive performance, accuracy of predicted market shares, extraction of behavioural indicators, and computational efficiency). We combine several real world datasets with synthetic datasets, where the data generation function is known. The results indicate that the models with the highest disaggregate predictive performance (namely extreme gradient boosting and random forests) provide poorer estimates of behavioural indicators and aggregate mode shares, and are more expensive to estimate, than other models, including deep neural networks and Multinomial Logit (MNL). It is further observed that the MNL model performs robustly in a variety of situations, though ML techniques can improve the estimates of behavioural indices such as Willingness to Pay.

Utilising physiological data for augmenting travel choice models: methodological frameworks and directions of future research

A Spatial Econometric Model for Travel Flow Analysis and Real-World Applications with Massive Mobile Phone Data

The Analysis of Dynamic Travel Mode Choice: A Heterogeneous Hidden Markov Approach

Multidimensional Travel Decision-Making: Descriptive Behavioural Theory And Agent-Based Models

A physiological model of human mobility: A global study

A Model for Using Physiological Conditions for Proactive Tourist Recommendations

Neurophysiological Measures in Hospitality and Tourism: Review, Critique, and Research Agenda

Quantitative modelling of cyclists' route choice behaviour on utilitarian trips based on GPS data: associated factors and behavioural implications

Analysis of Potential Shift to Low-Carbon Urban Travel Modes: A Computational Framework Based on High-Resolution Smartphone Data

Choosing Public Transport—Incorporating Richer Behavioural Elements in Modal Choice Models

Methodological Options and Data Sources for the Development of Long-Distance Passenger Travel Demand Models: A Comprehensive Review

Behavioral modeling of on-demand mobility services: general framework and application to sustainable travel incentives

Modelling Changes in Travel Behaviour Mechanisms Through a High-Order Hidden Markov Model

Influencing transport-health interactions through incentivised mode switch using new data and models

A Data-Driven Analytical Framework of Estimating Multimodal Travel Demand Patterns using Mobile Device Location Data

On the Application of Psychological Measurement Techniques to Travel Demand Estimation

Integrating Insights About Human Movement Patterns From Digital Data Into Psychological Science

The Role of Technophilia and User Goals in the Intention to Use a Mobility Management Travel App

Social vacation: Proposition of a model to understand tourists' usage of social media for travel planning

A deep causal inference model for fully-interpretable travel behaviour analysis

A prediction and behavioural analysis of machine learning methods for modelling travel mode choice