Abstract:The affordability, storage and power capacity of compact modern recording hardware have evolved passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) of animals and soundscapes into a non‐invasive, cost‐effective tool for research and ecological management particularly useful for bats and toothed whales that orient and forage using ultrasonic echolocation. The use of PAM at large scales hinges on effective automated detectors and species classifiers which, combined with distance sampling approaches, have enabled species abundance estimation of toothed whales. But standardized, user‐friendly and open access automated detection and classification workflows are in demand for this key conservation metric to be realized for bats. We used the PAMGuard toolbox including its new deep learning classification module to test the performance of four open‐source workflows for automated analyses of acoustic datasets from bats. Each workflow used a different initial detection algorithm followed by the same deep learning classification algorithm and was evaluated against the performance of an expert manual analyst. Workflow performance depended strongly on the signal‐to‐noise ratio and detection algorithm used: the full deep learning workflow had the best classification accuracy (≤67%) but was computationally too slow for practical large‐scale bat PAM. Workflows using PAMGuard's detection module or triggers onboard an SM4BAT or AudioMoth accurately classified up to 47%, 59% and 34%, respectively, of calls to species. Not all workflows included noise sampling critical to estimating changes in detection probability over time, a vital parameter for abundance estimation. The workflow using PAMGuard's detection module was 40 times faster than the full deep learning workflow and missed as few calls (recall for both ~0.6), thus balancing computational speed and performance. We show that complete acoustic detection and classification workflows for bat PAM data can be efficiently automated using open‐source software such as PAMGuard and exemplify how detection choices, whether pre‐ or post‐deployment, hardware or software‐driven, affect the performance of deep learning classification and the downstream ecological information that can be extracted from acoustic recordings. In particular, understanding and quantifying detection/classification accuracy and the probability of detection are key to avoid introducing biases that may ultimately affect the quality of data for ecological management.

A workflow for the automated detection and classification of female gibbon calls from long-term acoustic recordings

Automated detection of Bornean white-bearded gibbon (Hylobates albibarbis) vocalizations using an open-source framework for deep learning

Automated detection of Bornean white-bearded gibbon (Hylobates albibarbis) vocalisations using an open-source framework for deep learning

Automated detection of gibbon calls from passive acoustic monitoring data using convolutional neural networks in the "torch for R" ecosystem

Automated Call Detection for Acoustic Surveys with Structured Calls of Varying Length

Mel-frequency cepstral coefficients outperform embeddings from pre-trained convolutional neural networks under noisy conditions for discrimination tasks of individual gibbons

Benchmarking automated detection and classification approaches for monitoring of endangered species: a case study on gibbons from Cambodia

An integrated passive acoustic monitoring and deep learning pipeline for black‐and‐white ruffed lemurs (Varecia variegata) in Ranomafana National Park, Madagascar

Methods for processing and analyzing passive acoustic monitoring data: An example of song recognition in western black-crested gibbons

GIBBONFINDR: An R package for the detection and classification of acoustic signals

Automatic Sound Event Detection and Classification of Great Ape Calls Using Neural Networks

In the songs of Hainan gibbons: Automated individual dynamic monitoring from acoustic recordings

Using Deep Learning to Classify Environmental Sounds in the Habitat of Western Black-Crested Gibbons

Open‐source workflow approaches to passive acoustic monitoring of bats

Utilizing DeepSqueak for automatic detection and classification of mammalian vocalizations: a case study on primate vocalizations

Automatic standardized processing and identification of tropical bat calls using deep learning approaches

Applying Deep Neural Network to Automatic Recognition of Giant Panda Vocalizations

Using the ecological significance of animal vocalizations to improve inference in acoustic monitoring programs

Automatic Detection and Compression for Passive Acoustic Monitoring of the African Forest Elephant

Automated Bioacoustic Monitoring for South African Bird Species on Unlabeled Data

Implications of target signal choice in passive acoustic monitoring: an example of age‐ and sex‐dependent vocal repertoire use in African forest elephants (Loxodonta cyclotis)