Abstract:Background: An enriching learning environment is integral to resident wellness and education. Integrated vascular (VS) and general surgery (GS) residents share 18 months of core GS rotations during the postgraduate years 1-3 (PGY1-3); differences in their experiences may help identify practical levers for change. Methods: We used a convergent mixed-methods design. Cross-sectional surveys were administered after the 2020 American Board of Surgery In-Training Examination and Vascular Surgery In-Training Examination, assessing eight domains of the learning environment and resident wellness. Multivariable logistic regression models identified factors associated with thoughts of attrition between categorical PGY1-3 residents at 57 institutions with both GS and VS programs. Resident focus groups were conducted during the 2022 Vascular Annual Meeting to elicit more granular details about the experience of the learning environment. Transcripts were analyzed using inductive and deductive logics until thematic saturation was achieved. Results: Surveys were completed by 205 VS and 1198 GS PGY1-3 residents (response rates 76.8% for VS and 82.5% for GS). After adjusting for resident demographics, PGY level, and program type, GS residents were more likely than their VS peers to consider leaving their programs (odds ratio [OR]: 2.61, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.37-4.99). This finding did not persist after adjusting for differences in perceptions of the learning environment, specifically: GS residents had higher odds of mistreatment (OR: 1.99, 95% CI: 1.36-2.90), poorer work-life integration (OR: 2.88, 95% CI: 1.41-5.87), less resident camaraderie (OR: 3.51, 95% CI: 2.26-5.45), and decreased meaning in work (OR: 2.94, 95% CI: 1.80-4.83). Qualitative data provided insight into how the shared learning environment was perceived differently: (1) vascular trainees expressed that early specialization and a smaller, more invested faculty allow for an apprenticeship model with early operative exposure, hands-on guidance, frequent feedback, and thus early skill acquisition (meaning in work); (2) a smaller program is conducive to closer relationships with co-residents and faculty, increasing familiarity (camaraderie and work-life integration); and (3) due to increased familiarity with program leadership, vascular trainees feel more comfortable reporting mistreatment, allowing for prompt responses (mistreatment). Conclusions: Despite sharing a learning environment, VS and GS residents experience training differently, contributing to differential thoughts of attrition. These differences may be attributable to intrinsic features of the integrated training paradigm that are not easily replicated by GS programs, such as smaller program size and higher faculty investment due to early specialization. Alternative strategies to compensate for these inherent differences should be considered (eg, structured operative entrustment programs and faculty incentivization).

Faculty perception of resident promotion and prevention associated behaviors in the operating room to facilitate intra-operative learning

Improving the Intraoperative Educational Experience: Understanding the Role of Confidence in the Resident-Attending Relationship

A comparison of personality traits, learning style, and perceived stress among surgical and nonsurgical residents in a tertiary care hospital in India

Comparison of the Perspectives of Medical Students and Residents on the Surgery Learning Environment

Measuring Chief Resident Skill and Entrustment Progression in An Operative Coaching Program: Four Years’ Experience

Improving resident well-being and clinical learning environment through academic initiatives

Analysis of Operating Room Personnel Perspectives to Enhance Medical Student Readiness for Surgery

Fake It 'Til You Make It: Pressures to Measure Up in Surgical Training

Intensive Care Unit Educators: A Multicenter Evaluation of Behaviors Residents Value in Attending Physicians

Perception of shared learning environment differs between vascular surgery and general surgery residents

Through the Looking Glass: Comparing Resident and Attending Views on Competency and Autonomy

Implementation of an Online Intraoperative Assessment of Technical Performance for Surgical Trainees

Holding the Knife on Perceptions of Surgery

Education of the modern surgical resident: novel approaches to learning in the era of the 80-hour workweek

Resident Operative Autonomy in Robotic Surgery Training: Unpacking Gender Disparities and Training Trends

Tracking operative autonomy and performance in otolaryngology training using smartphone technology: A single institution pilot study

Surgical Resident Burnout and Job Satisfaction: The Role of Workplace Climate and Perceived Support

Surgical Residents as Clerkship Scholars May Improve Student Perception of the Surgery Clerkship

Disparity of perspectives between teachers and learners on perioperative teaching and learning

Faculty Entrustment and Resident Entrustability

Identifying Novel Inhibitors of Workplace Support and the Importance of Value Congruence and Feeling Valued in General Surgery Residency Training