Evolution and spread of multiadapted pathogens in a spatially heterogeneous environment

Quentin Griette,Matthieu Alfaro,Gaël Raoul,Sylvain Gandon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/evlett/qrad073

2024-01-31

Evolution Letters

Abstract:Abstract Pathogen adaptation to multiple selective pressures challenges our ability to control their spread. Here we analyze the evolutionary dynamics of pathogens spreading in a heterogeneous host population where selection varies periodically in space. We study both the transient dynamics taking place at the front of the epidemic and the long-term evolution far behind the front. We identify five types of epidemic profiles arising for different levels of spatial heterogeneity and different costs of adaptation. In particular, we identify the conditions where a generalist pathogen carrying multiple adaptations can outrace a coalition of specialist pathogens. We also show that finite host populations promote the spread of generalist pathogens because demographic stochasticity enhances the extinction of locally maladapted pathogens. But higher mutation rates between genotypes can rescue the coalition of specialists and speed up the spread of epidemics for intermediate levels of spatial heterogeneity. Our work provides a comprehensive analysis of the interplay between migration, local selection, mutation, and genetic drift on the spread and on the evolution of pathogens in heterogeneous environments. This work extends our fundamental understanding of the outcome of the competition between two specialists and a generalist strategy (single- vs. multiadapted pathogens). These results have practical implications for the design of more durable control strategies against multiadapted pathogens in agriculture and in public health.

evolutionary biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how pathogens adapt to multiple selection pressures in a spatially heterogeneous environment and explores the impact of this adaptation on the spread rate of pathogens. Specifically, the research focuses on the evolutionary dynamics of pathogens and their transmission characteristics in the case of periodic spatial variation in the host population. The paper analyzes the competitive relationship between single - adapted pathogens (specialist pathogens) and multi - adapted pathogens (generalist pathogens), and how these relationships affect the spread rate and distribution pattern of pathogens.

### Main problems
1. **Pathogen adaptability and transmission**:
- Research on the adaptive changes of pathogens in a spatially heterogeneous environment, especially how pathogens with different adaptation strategies (such as single - adaptation and multi - adaptation) compete in such an environment.
- Analyze how these adaptation strategies affect the spread rate of pathogens and the final epidemiological characteristics.

2. **Impact of spatial heterogeneity**:
- Explore how the spatial heterogeneity of the host population (for example, different types of hosts are distributed in different areas) affects the spread of pathogens.
- Identify five different epidemiological characteristics that may occur under different levels of spatial heterogeneity and adaptation cost conditions.

3. **Role of genetic drift and mutation**:
- Research how genetic drift in a limited host population promotes the spread of multi - adapted pathogens.
- Explore how the mutation rate between different genotypes affects the spread rate of pathogens, especially under conditions of moderate spatial heterogeneity.

### Specific research content
- **Model establishment**: Use the reaction - diffusion equation model to describe the spread dynamics of pathogens in the host population, taking into account the infection status of the host (uninfected and infected), the spread rate of pathogens, the mortality rate, and mutations between genotypes.
- **Spread rate analysis**: Explore the impact of spatial heterogeneity, mutation rate, and genetic drift on the spread of pathogens by analyzing the spread rate under different conditions.
- **Epidemiological characteristics**: Identify and describe five different epidemiological characteristics, which depend on the degree of spatial heterogeneity and the growth rate of multi - adapted pathogens.

### Practical applications
- **Disease control strategies**: The research results are helpful for designing more sustainable disease control strategies, especially in the fields of agriculture and public health. By optimizing the composition of the host population, the spread rate of epidemics can be reduced and the evolution of multi - adapted pathogens can be limited.

### Key conclusions
- **Advantages of multi - adapted pathogens**: Under certain conditions, multi - adapted pathogens can outperform single - adapted pathogens, especially when the spatial heterogeneity is low and the adaptation cost is low.
- **Impact of mutation rate**: A higher mutation rate can accelerate the spread of epidemics to a certain extent, especially under conditions of moderate spatial heterogeneity.
- **Role of genetic drift**: Genetic drift in a limited host population can enhance the extinction of locally maladapted pathogens, thereby promoting the spread of multi - adapted pathogens.

Through these studies, the paper provides an important theoretical basis for understanding the spread mechanism of pathogens in complex environments and provides a scientific basis for practical disease control.