Modeling of capillary force between particles with unequal contact angle

Dongling Wu,Ping Zhou,Geoff Wang,Baojun Zhao,Tony Howes,Wei Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.powtec.2020.08.037

IF: 5.64

2020-10-01

Powder Technology

Abstract:<p>When two particles with a thin liquid film are colliding toward each other, liquid films merge to form a pendular liquid bridge, which may induce a strong capillary force. The capillary force is determined by the particle size as well as contact parameters, such as liquid volume, contact angles of liquid on each particle, and the separation distance. Upon considering all these impacting factors, a general and explicit capillary force model was established in this study with a minimal energy method by using the software-Surface Evolver. The developed model was validated by comparing results with those obtained through an analytical expression and previous closed-form models. The developed capillary force model is capable of predicting the capillary force between two particles with different diameters and contact angles (≤50°) with an error of less than 15%.</p>

engineering, chemical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects:

1. **Comparing the solution spaces of the σ - model and the Nambu - Goto model**:
- The paper explores whether the solution spaces of the σ - model and the Nambu - Goto model are the same in the case of the four - gluon amplitude ($n = 4$). Although the classical actions of these two models are different, the paper finds that their moduli space dimensions are the same, that is, $\text{dim}(M_\sigma^4)=\text{dim}(M_{\text{NG}}^4)$.
- However, although these moduli spaces have the same dimension, their specific forms are different. The basic modular parameters in the σ - model are the ratio $\frac{z_1z_3}{z_2z_4}$ and the angle $\phi$, while in the Nambu - Goto model, the basic modular parameters are the angle $\phi$ and the ratio of the lengths of two vectors $\frac{|\vec{k}_1|}{|\vec{k}_2|}$.

2. **Generalization to the five - gluon amplitude ($n = 5$)**:
- The paper attempts to guess the form of the regularized action $A_n(z_1,z_2,\ldots,z_n;\epsilon)$ of the five - gluon amplitude and reproduce the one - loop amplitude $F^{(1)}_5$ of the BDDK formula by minimizing this action.
- To achieve this goal, the paper proposes a constraint condition $\sum_{a < b}z_az_bt_{ab}=1$ and minimizes the action under this constraint. Eventually, the paper obtains a result consistent with the BDDK formula.

### Specific content summary:

- **Solution spaces of the σ - model and the Nambu - Goto model**:
- For the case of $n = 4$, the paper finds that although the solution spaces of the σ - model and the Nambu - Goto model have the same dimension, their specific forms are different. The basic modular parameters in the σ - model are the ratio $\frac{z_1z_3}{z_2z_4}$ and the angle $\phi$, while in the Nambu - Goto model, the basic modular parameters are the angle $\phi$ and the ratio of the lengths of two vectors $\frac{|\vec{k}_1|}{|\vec{k}_2|}$.
- The paper also discusses the relationship between these two models and points out that because the Virasoro constraint is not considered, these two models are actually different.

- **Regularized action of the five - gluon amplitude**:
- The paper assumes that there is a parameter set $\{z_a\}$ describing the solution of the σ - model and introduces a regularization scheme and a constraint condition.
- By minimizing the action $A_n(z_1,z_2,\ldots,z_n;\epsilon)$ and applying the constraint condition $\sum_{a < b}z_az_bt_{ab}=1$, the paper obtains a result consistent with the BDDK formula.
- Eventually, the paper derives the expression of the finite part of the five - gluon amplitude, which can be regarded as a natural generalization of the BDDK formula.

### Conclusion:

By comparing the solution spaces of the σ - model and the Nambu - Goto model, the paper reveals that in the case of the four - gluon amplitude, these two models have the same dimension but different specific forms. In addition, the paper successfully guesses and verifies the form of the regularized action of the five - gluon amplitude, providing valuable guidance for subsequent research.