Abstract:There is little disagreement among insurance actuaries and financial economists about the societal benefits of longevity-risk pooling in the form of life annuities, defined benefit pensions, self-annuitization funds, and even tontine schemes. Indeed, the discounted value or cost of providing an income for life is lower -- in other words, the amount of upfront capital required to generate a similar income stream with the same level of statistical safety is lower -- when participants pool their financial resources versus going it alone. Moreover, when participants' financial circumstances and lifespans are homogenous, there is consensus on how to share the "winnings" among survivors, namely by distributing them equally among survivors, a.k.a. a uniform rule. Alas, what is lesser-known and much more problematic is allocating the winnings in such a pool when participants differ in wealth (contributions) and health (longevity), especially when the pools are relatively small in size. The same problems arise when viewed from the dual perspective of decentralized risk sharing (DRS). The positive correlation between health and income and the fact that wealthier participants are likely to live longer is a growing concern among pension and retirement policymakers. With that motivation in mind, this paper offers a modelling framework for distributing longevity-risk pools' income and benefits (or tontine winnings) when participants are heterogeneous. Similar to the nascent literature on decentralized risk sharing, there are several equally plausible arrangements for sharing benefits (a.k.a. "skinning the cat") among survivors. Moreover, the selected rule depends on the extent of social cohesion within the longevity risk pool, ranging from solidarity and altruism to pure individualism. In sum, actuarial science cannot really offer or guarantee uniqueness, only a methodology.

A sharing rule for multi-period interest-sensitive insurance contracts

Valuation of Information-Sharing in Marine Mutual Insurance

Multiperiod peer‐to‐peer risk sharing

The Risk-Sharing problem under limited liability constraints in a single-period model

Surplus Sharing with Coherent Utility Functions

Information, Incentives, and Effects of Risk-Sharing on the Real Economy

A fixed point approach for computing actuarially fair Pareto optimal risk-sharing rules

Optimal capital allocations to interdependent actuarial risks

Indifference pricing of insurance-linked securities in a multi-period model

Quantile-based risk sharing with heterogeneous beliefs

Sharing of longevity basis risk in pension schemes with income-drawdown guarantees

Mean-variance longevity risk-sharing for annuity contracts

Axiomatic characterizations of some simple risk-sharing rules

Optimal Sharing Rule for a Household with a Portfolio Management Problem

Optimal Reinsurance Pricing, Risk Sharing and Investment Strategies in a Joint Reinsurer-Insurer Framework

Time-consistent Reinsurance and Investment Strategy Combining Quota-Share and Excess of Loss for Mean-Variance Insurers with Jump-Diffusion Price Process

'Egalitarian pooling and sharing of longevity risk', a.k.a. 'The many ways to skin a tontine cat'

Composite time-consistent multi-period risk measure and its application in optimal portfolio selection

Multiperiod Portfolio Selection On A Minimax Rule

Time-consistent mean-variance risk sharing and reinsurance for an insurance group in a Stackelberg differential game

Multi-Period Risk Measures and Optimal Investment Policies