Machine Learning Research Trends in Traditional Chinese Medicine: A Bibliometric Review
Jiekee Lim,Jieyun Li,Mi Zhou,Xinang Xiao,Zhaoxia Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/ijgm.s495663
IF: 2.145
2024-11-27
International Journal of General Medicine
Abstract:Jiekee Lim, 1 Jieyun Li, 1 Mi Zhou, 1 Xinang Xiao, 1 Zhaoxia Xu 1, 2 1 School of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, People's Republic of China; 2 Shanghai Key Laboratory of Health Identification and Assessment, Shanghai, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Zhaoxia Xu, School of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, 201203, People's Republic of China, Email Background: Integrating Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) knowledge with modern technology, especially machine learning (ML), has shown immense potential in enhancing TCM diagnostics and treatment. This study aims to systematically review and analyze the trends and developments in ML applications in TCM through a bibliometric analysis. Methods: Data for this study were sourced from the Web of Science Core Collection. Data were analyzed and visualized using Microsoft Office Excel, Bibliometrix, and VOSviewer. Results: 474 documents were identified. The analysis revealed a significant increase in research output from 2000 to 2023, with China leading in both the number of publications and research impact. Key research institutions include the Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine and the China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences. Major research hotspots identified include ML applications in TCM diagnosis, network pharmacology, and tongue diagnosis. Additionally, chemometrics with ML are highlighted for their roles in quality control and authentication of TCM products. Conclusion: This study provides a comprehensive overview of ML applications' development trends and research landscape in TCM. The integration of ML has led to significant advancements in TCM diagnostics, personalized medicine, and quality control, paving the way for the modernization and internationalization of TCM practices. Future research should focus on improving model interpretability, fostering international collaborations, and standardized reporting protocols. Keywords: artificial intelligence, bibliometric, machine learning, review, traditional Chinese medicine Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), with its unique theoretical system and treatment methods, has a rich history spanning thousands of years. However, despite its profound heritage, TCM faces significant challenges in modern medical research due to its inherent complexity and the qualitative nature of its diagnostic and therapeutic systems. One major obstacle is the gap between TCM's holistic and often subjective framework and the data-driven, quantitative nature of modern scientific methodologies, including machine learning (ML). Therefore, integrating traditional TCM knowledge with modern technology is a crucial research area in contemporary TCM studies. Machine learning (ML) is a field within artificial intelligence (AI) that develops algorithms that enable computers to learn and improve from experience and data without explicit programming. 1,2 ML has shown immense potential in the medical field in recent years. 3 ML algorithms can process and analyze vast amounts of data, uncovering hidden patterns and associations within the data. This capability is particularly valuable for TCM areas, such as disease diagnosis, syndrome differentiation, and Chinese herbal medicine analysis. For instance, Chen and He highlighted the importance of ML in TCM, showing how these algorithms can enhance research efficiency and accuracy by extracting valuable insights from large datasets. 4 Applying ML to TCM research has led to significant breakthroughs. For example, a study utilized ML techniques to analyze TCM's four diagnostic methods, successfully predicting the progression of chronic diseases. 5 The study trained algorithms capable of recognizing disease patterns by analyzing extensive patient diagnostic data, providing a new diagnostic tool for TCM. 5 Analyzing large-scale clinical data through ML enhances our understanding of TCM's mechanisms of action and elucidates the differential responses of various constitutions to treatments, thus advancing personalized medicine. Bibliometric analysis, a scientific method involving the quantitative assessment of literature data, 6 is particularly important for understanding ML research in TCM. This method helps researchers identify research hotspots and trends in the TCM-ML field. Visualization tools such as network maps and trend graphs provide a clear depiction of research structures and evolution paths. Through this bibliometric analysis, we aim to systematically comprehend the development trends and research landscape in this field, offer -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal