Abstract:Abstract. Ship emission estimates diverge widely for all chemical compounds for several reasons: use of different methodologies (bottom-up or top-down), activity data and emission factors can easily result in a difference ranging from a factor of 1.5 to even an order of magnitude. Combining three sets of observational data – ozone and black carbon measurements sampled at three coastal sites and on board of a Mediterranean cruise ship, as well as satellite observations of atmospheric NO2 column concentration over the same area – we assess the accuracy of the three most commonly used ship emission inventories, EDGAR FT (Olivier et al., 2005), emissions described by Eyring et al. (2005) and emissions reported by EMEP (Vestreng et al., 2007). Our tool is a global atmospheric chemistry transport model which simulates the chemical state of the Mediterranean atmosphere applying different ship emission inventories. The simulated contributions of ships to air pollutant levels in the Mediterranean atmosphere are significant but strongly depend on the inventory applied. Close to the major shipping routes relative contributions vary from 10 to 50% for black carbon and from 2 to 12% for ozone in the surface layer, as well as from 5 to 20% for nitrogen dioxide atmospheric column burden. The relative contributions are still significant over the North African coast, but less so over the South European coast because densely populated regions with significant human activity contribute relatively more to air pollution than ships, even if these regions attract a lot of ship traffic. The observations poorly constrain the ship emission inventories in the Eastern Mediterranean where the influence of uncertain land based emissions, the model transport and wet deposition are at least as important as the signal from ships. In the Western Mediterranean, the regional EMEP emission inventory gives the best match with most measurements, followed by Eyring for NO2 and ozone and by EDGAR for black carbon. Given the uncertainty of the measurements and the model, each of the three emission inventories could actually be right, implying that large uncertainties in ship emissions need to be considered for future scenario analysis.

Potential impact of shipping on air pollution in the Mediterranean region – a multimodel evaluation: comparison of photooxidants NO2 and O3

What can we learn about ship emission inventories from measurements of air pollutants over the Mediterranean Sea?

Modelling of air pollution due to marine traffic in Marseille

Perspectives on Shipping Emissions and Their Impacts on the Surface Ocean and Lower Atmosphere: an Environmental-Social-economic Dimension

Comparison of the Impact of Ship Emissions in Northern Europe and Eastern China

Assessment of freight traffic flows and harmful emissions in euro-mediterranean context: scenario analyses based on a gravity model

Impact of shipping emissions regulation on urban aerosol composition changes revealed by receptor and numerical modelling

Chemical interactions between ship‐originated air pollutants and ocean‐emitted halogens

Atmospheric Impacts and Regulation Framework of Shipping Emissions: Achievements, Challenges and Frontiers

Emission Evaluation of Marine Traffic

Impact of air emissions from shipping on marine phytoplankton growth

Using the Multicomponent Aerosol FORmation Model (MAFOR) to Determine Improved VOC Emission Factors in Ship Plumes

Assessing the emissions of short sea international shipping: a case study of the Mytilini-Ayvalik route

The climate impact of high seas shipping

A comprehensive inventory of the ship traffic exhaust emissions in the Baltic Sea from 2006 to 2009

Ambient measurement of shipping emissions in Shanghai port areas

MAX-DOAS observations of ship emissions in the North Sea

Shipping emissions and their impacts on air quality in China

Global health benefits of shipping emission reduction in early 2020

Atmospheric pollution from ships and its impact on local air quality at a port site in Shanghai

Ambient marine shipping emissions determined by vessel operation mode along the East China Sea