"The Riddle of the Ages": James Joseph Sylvester and the Transcendence of π

Adrian Rice
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00029890.2024.2322944
2024-03-29
American Mathematical Monthly
Abstract:The first proof of the transcendence of π by Ferdinand Lindemann in 1882 prompted the publication of a wave of further proofs, all attempting to elucidate, simplify, or generalize this epoch-making result. Modifications by the likes of Weierstrass, Gordan, and Hilbert all entered the literature. But one such proof sank without a trace and was almost completely ignored. This is surprising as, not only did it appear in a major journal with a large international readership, but it was also written by one of the most famous mathematicians of the time—James Joseph Sylvester. This paper tells its story.
mathematics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?