Socio-economic Status Exceeds Executive Function as a Central Role Player in Academic Achievement of Grade 7 Primary School Boys and Girls: the NW-CHILD Study

Elna De Waal,Ankebé Kruger,Anita E. Pienaar
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s43076-022-00252-w
2023-01-24
Trends in Psychology
Abstract:Executive function is a complex set of mental processes playing a key role in children's academic performance. However, environmental influences on the contribution of executive function to academic achievement in older children are still unclear. This study investigated the relationship between executive function and academic achievement and the role of socio-economic status (SES) in this relationship, in grade 7 learners. A cross-sectional analysis (as part of a longitudinal study, NW-CHILD study, 2010–2016) was conducted and included 272 12-year-old (± 0.42) randomly selected South-African children (80 boys, 79 girls from low SES; 68 boys, 45 girls from high SES). SES was determined using the South African school quintile status system. Executive function was measured by the Tower of London (TOL DX ), Second Edition, and academic achievement using the North-West Provincial Assessment (NWPA) and mid-year school assessment results. Spearman rank-order correlation coefficients ( r ) indicated minor to intermediate correlations between quantitative performance aspects of executive function and mathematics ( r = 0.12–0.20), languages ( r = 0.12–0.14), and overall academic achievement ( r = 0.13–0.17). Hierarchical linear modelling revealed significantly ( p < 0.05) poorer academic achievement ( d = 0.31–1.31) and executive function ( d = 0.23–0.47) among participants from low SES schools. Gender differences in the relation between executive function, SES, and academic achievement were evident. Inhibitory control became more relevant for achievement in mathematics, especially in boys. In conclusion, executive function plays an essential role in academic achievement of 12-year-old children. The effect of SES, however, does exceed executive function as a key role player. Children from low SES backgrounds are especially vulnerable.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?