Abstract:We examine two aspects of the mathematical basis for two-tier voting systems, such as that of the Council of the European Union. These aspects concern the use of square-root weights and the choice of quota.Square-root weights originate in the Penrose square-root system, which assumes that votes are cast independently and uniformly at random, and is based around the concept of equality of influence of the voters across the Union. There are (at least) two distinct definitions of influence in current use in probability theory, namely, absolute and conditional influence. These are in agreement when the underlying random variables are independent, but not generally. We review their possible implications for two-tier voting systems, especially in the context of the so-called collective bias model. We show that the two square-root laws invoked by Penrose are unified through the use of conditional influence.In an elaboration of the square-root system, Słomczyński and Życzkowskihave proposed an exact value for the quota <math>q=q∗</math> to be achieved in a successful vote of a two-tier system, and they have presented numerical and theoretical evidence in its support. We indicate some numerical and mathematical issues arising in the use of a Gaussian (or normal) approximation in this context, and we propose that other values of <math>q</math> may be as good if not better than <math>q∗</math>. We discuss certain aspects of the relationship between theoreticians and politicians in the design of a two-tier voting system, and we reach the conclusion that the choice of quota in the square-root system is an issue for politicians informed by theory.

Invariably Suboptimal - An attempt to improve the voting rules of Treaties of Nice and Lisbon

Voting in the European Union: The square root system of Penrose and a critical point

Square root voting in the Council of the European Union: Rounding effects and the Jagiellonian Compromise

Voting power and Qualified Majority Voting with a "no vote" option

On influence and compromise in two-tier voting systems

Penrose voting system and optimal quota

Voting power in the Council of the European Union: A comprehensive sensitivity analysis

Square Root Voting System, Optimal Threshold and π

Are Weighted Games Sufficiently Good for Binary Voting?

Dimension of the Lisbon voting rules in the EU Council: a challenge and new world record

Double Majority and Generalized Brexit: Explaining Counterintuitive Results

A power-weighted variant of the EU27 Cambridge Compromise

Fair representation and a linear Shapley rule

An upper bound on the dimension of the voting system of the European Union Council under the Lisbon rules

Alternatives to plurality rule for single-winner elections: When do they make a difference?

Allocation of seats in the European Parliament and a degressive proportionality

Optimal Policymaking under Yardstick Vote: an Experimental Study

Committee Scoring Rules: Axiomatic Characterization and Hierarchy

Dynamic adjustment: an electoral method for relaxed double proportionality

Influence in Weighted Committees

Crowdsourcing for Participatory Democracies: Efficient Elicitation of Social Choice Functions