Is European enlargement policy a form of non-democracy promotion?

Dušan Pavlović
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41268-022-00286-8
2023-01-08
Journal of International Relations and Development
Abstract:Can the theory of autocracy promotion learn something from the most recent erosion in democracy seen across the Western Balkans (WB)? The case of the WB is interesting because it takes place within the context of the EU enlargement process, which is a form of democratic promotion (dissemination). I argue that the current version of the EU enlargement process is a form of hybrid regime enabling rather than democracy dissemination. My major claim is that the significant driver for autocratic tendencies and the authoritarian stability of these regimes comes from within the EU enlargement process and only subsequently from these regimes' internal political dynamics and other autocracies' influences. I offer several contributions to the existing research on autocracy and democracy promotion. I model the problem as a strategic bargaining game between the promoter and receiver. The EU Commission is prepared to tolerate a certain level of authoritarianism in the WB countries for two reasons: if the WB incumbent guarantees stability and accepts the Euro-Atlantic policy, the outcome is a hybrid regime with less likelihood to transform into some form of autocracy.
political science,international relations
What problem does this paper attempt to address?