Normative versus transformative coaching approaches: Profiling the social justice activism and allyship of Canadian high school sport coaches
Evan Bishop,Martin Camiré,Leisha Strachan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10413200.2024.2437183
2024-12-11
Journal of Applied Sport Psychology
Abstract:In Canada, high school sport is a popular activity used to foster the physical and psychosocial development of student-athletes. Despite the popularity of high school sport, social justice inequities (e.g., racism, ableism) continue to shape student-athletes' experiences. Given that the mission of School Sport Canada (i.e., the national governing body of school sport) is to facilitate the "total development of student athletes through interscholastic sport", there is a need to study the way coaches think about and act for social justice. Thus, the purpose of the study was to profile the social justice activism and allyship of Canadian high school coaches. Semi-structured interviews were conducted virtually (i.e., via Zoom) with 28 Canadian high school sport coaches. Interview data were subjected to reflexive thematic analysis, which led to the development of two coach profiles based on the two continua model for life skills teaching (Camiré, Citation 2023 ). The two coaching profiles – the normative coaching approach (i.e., general disinterest in social justice) and the transformative coaching approach (i.e., proactive social justice activism through a developed critical consciousness) – are contrasted across four overarching themes (a) I'm (Not) Confident, I (Don't) Understand; (b) (Un)intentionally (Re)acting; (c) You See Excuses, I See Obstacles to be Toppled; and (d) (Dis)engaged and (Non)autonomous Education. Findings have practical implications for centering social justice in coach education, for developing critical praxis related to activism and allyship, and for instigating systemic policy changes that can make the Canadian school sport system safer, more equitable, and more inclusive for all participants. Interviews were conducted with 28 Canadian high school sport coaches and were subsequently analyzed to form two profiles: the normative coaching approach (i.e., disinterest in social justice) and the transformative coaching approach (i.e., social justice activism). Findings suggest the need to shift toward a transformative approach in Canadian high school sport coaching.
sport sciences,psychology, applied,hospitality, leisure, sport & tourism