Abstract:Background: The use of fitness tests in physical education (PE) receives extensive scrutiny and represents one of the most fiercely debated topics in PE research. Fitness test proponents often provide unwavering support citing their positive long-term benefits while critics underscore the corrosive long-term pitfalls associated with their use in PE. In many instances, both proponents and critics alike make these arguments with limited evidence to support their claims. Recently, critics have also highlighted the gendered nature of fitness tests, reporting that overt characteristics of these tests and their implementation create covert messages that reduce girls' motivation toward PE. Therefore, there is a clear need to gather evidence concerning the effects that fitness tests have on students' subjective experiences in PE.Purpose: The purposes of this study were twofold. First, we examine relationships between middle school students' fitness test performances and their future attitudes and emotions toward PE. Second, we investigate how these relationships vary for girls and boys.Method: A total of 273 middle school students (6th-8th grade; Male = 52%, Female = 48%) completed Fitnessgram™ battery of tests. Two weeks later, students completed two previously validated surveys about: a) their attitudes, and b) their discreet emotions (enjoyment, boredom, and anger) toward PE. First, structural equation modeling (SEM) was used to evaluate relationships for the entire sample. Once this baseline model was established, multi-group SEM identified similarities and differences in the pattern of relationships between girls and boys.Results: Findings revealed that better PACER performance predicted lower reports of future anger toward PE for both girls and boys. Conversely, increased performance on the curl-up test predicted higher rates of anger and lower rates of enjoyment toward PE. Increased PACER performance also predicted favorable attitudes for boys but not girls while increased sit-and-reach performance predicted favorable attitudes for girls but not boys. It should be noted, however, that fitness test performances explained limited amounts of variance in these outcomes, especially for girls.Conclusions: Unlike the common arguments about the valuable or harmful effects of fitness testing, our results suggested these tests had limited associations with students' future attitudes and emotions toward PE. Overall, we remain pessimistic about the use of fitness tests in PE because these PE teachers implemented fitness tests in isolation of the broader PE curriculum. Scores were neither shared with parents/guardians nor used to help students learn about their fitness. Students did not compare their results to previous tests and, to our knowledge, scores were not used for any large-scale surveillance purposes. It remains unclear how fitness test performances relate to student attitudes and emotions toward PE when implemented in a comprehensive and connected manner within the broader curriculum.

Improving Use of Physical Fitness Testing Data in Middle Schools to Inform Equitable School-wide Physical Activity Practices: A Mixed-methods Approach

The if, why and how of fitness testing in secondary school physical education in the United Kingdom

Teachers' Use of Fitness Tests in School-Based Physical Education Programs

Associations of physical fitness and academic performance among schoolchildren

Disseminating Evidence-Based Physical Education Practices in Rural Schools: The San Luis Valley Physical Education Academy

Benefits of Strength and Skill-based Training During Primary School Physical Education

Supporting Students’ Physical Activity Self-Efficacy within High School Physical Education

Elementary school staff perspectives on the implementation of physical activity approaches in practice: an exploratory sequential mixed methods study

Do fitness test performances predict students’ attitudes and emotions toward physical education?

Teaching healthy behaviour knowledge in primary school physical education

Improving Physical Fitness and Cognitive Functions in Middle School Students: Study Protocol for the Chinese Childhood Health, Activity and Motor Performance Study (Chinese CHAMPS)

Impact on Physical Fitness of the Chinese CHAMPS: A Clustered Randomized Controlled Trial

Effects of daily physical education on physical fitness and weight status in middle school adolescents

Children’s Physical Fitness and Academic Performance

Effectiveness of a School-Based Fitness Program on Youths' Physical and Psychosocial Health Outcomes

An expansive learning approach to transforming traditional fitness testing in health and physical education: student voice, feelings and hopes

Health-related physical fitness and physical activity in elementary school students

Process evaluation and challenges in collecting data from an after-school sports and literacy program in a diverse, low-income community

Students’ perceptions of fitness testing in physical education across primary, secondary, and pre-university school levels: a motivational profiles perspective

Physical fitness disparities among New York City public school youth using standardized methods, 2006-2017

Physical Education and Physical Activity: Results From the School Health Policies and Programs Study 2006