A Comparative Evaluation of Seepage and Stability of Embankment Dams Using GeoStudio and Plaxis Models: the Case of Gomit Dam in Amhara Region, Ethiopia
Amanuel Zewdu Belew,Solomon Kegne Belay,Mekete Dessie Wosenie,Neway Asrat Alemie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41101-022-00152-1
2022-06-02
Water Conservation Science and Engineering
Abstract:This paper presents an evaluation and comparative study on the seepage and slope stability analysis of the Gomit earth dam found in the Amhara Region, South Gondar Zone, Estie woreda. The analysis was performed using limit equilibrium (LE) and finite element (FE) methods in GeoStudio 2012 and Plaxis 2D 8.2 models. Field data measurements and observatory investigations were also carried out. Seepage analysis such as seepage magnitude, pore water pressure distribution, and location of the phreatic line has been determined using SEEP/W and Plaxis models. From the simulated results of SEEP/W and Plaxis models, the average seepage rate for the entire length of the dam at full reservoir conditions was found to be 2.632 × 10−5 m3/s and 7.497 × 10−4 m3/s, respectively. Three different loading conditions (end-of-construction, steady-state seepage, and rapid drawdown) have been studied for stability analysis. The factor of safety results of SLOPE/W at the end of construction, steady-state, and rapid drawdown conditions were 1.045, 1.473, and 1.012 and the corresponding results of Plaxis model were 0.818, 1.402, and 0.945, respectively. The stability analysis results for the designed conditions show that the slopes are unstable under all loading conditions. The actual site investigations of the dam, in line with the model results, indicated that the downstream slope is facing a stability problem. From this model and actual site investigation studies, we understand that currently the dam safety and performance are not satisfactory (high leakage and slope instability). Hence, it is recommended to conduct critical monitoring and surveillance of the dam and the stability results of the Plaxis model are generally smaller than the results of the SLOPE/W model. For the slope stability analysis of embankment dams, where there is high uncertainty in the soil data of dam construction, the Plaxis model may be better since it gives conservative factor of safety results based on this study. However, still additional evaluation of the models is necessary and designers have to note the different considerations of the models in applying and selecting the models.