Abstract:Moral self-regulation, the dynamic process through which an individual’s moral behavior history influences subsequent moral action, includes a negative-feedback mechanism. When people recall their own moral (immoral) behavior, moral self-perception will deviate from the ideal moral self-image, motivating them to engage in decreased (increased) moral action or increased (decreased) immoral action to compensate their bolstered (threatened) moral self-perception, and thereby activating a moral licensing (cleansing) effect. Whereas moral licensing and cleansing have been frequently reported in studies on prosocial behavior, less is so in rule infraction (e.g., cheating). In the current study, the authors designed two experiments to study the effects of moral self-regulation on prosocial behavior and rule infraction. We predicted that after moral (immoral) priming, participants would demonstrate less (more) charitable giving and more (less) cheating. Moreover, because people are more motivated to avoid harms than to approach benefits, the moral self-regulation process may be asymmetric in terms of prescriptive morality (what we should do) versus proscriptive morality (what we should not do). Specifically, we hypothesized that moral licensing would be more readily observed in charitable giving than in cheating; in contrast, we expected the reverse in moral cleansing. In Study 1, 155 undergraduate students were randomly assigned into positive-traits, negative-traits, or neutral-words condition. In each condition, participants were asked to copy a list of positive or negative moral traits, or inanimate objects; they were also instructed to recall past self-experience relevant to the keywords that they had copied. After the priming task, participants were invited to make a hypothetical donation. A one-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was conducted to examine the influence of moral priming on the amount of money that participants intended to donate. In Study 2, 96 undergraduate students' moral self-perception was manipulated using the same method as that in Study 1. Then, participants' cheating behavior was observed. A 3×2 contingency table and a one-way ANCOVA were conducted to explore the effects of moral priming on the occurrence rates and severity of cheating among the three conditions, respectively. Results indicated that participants in the positive-traits condition were more willing to donate higher amount of money than those in the negative-traits and neutral-words conditions (Study 1). Moreover, participants in both experimental conditions were less likely to engage in cheating than those in the control condition, and their cheating behavior was less severe (Study 2). Taken together, the current study partially confirmed the moral cleansing effect in the proscriptive, but not the prescriptive morality system. However, the opposite of moral licensing effect was observed in both conditions. In conclusion, the motivational mechanism of moral action could be far more complex than previously suggested. For one thing, the self-regulation process could be different in prescriptive versus proscriptive morality. For another, people's moral action may be influenced by both moral self-regulation (a compensatory process) as well as moral identity (a consistent process). To better understand and predict moral actions, future research should investigate both processes in the contexts of proscriptive and prescriptive moralities.

The role of moral identity and regret on cheating in sport

A Study on the Conceptual Ambiguity of Cheating in Sport

The influence of psychological needs and motivation on game cheating: insights from self-determination theory

Cheating and gaming the system in ancient athletics

Perception of Cheaters: The Role of Past and Present Academic Achievement

Perceived Motivational Climates and Doping Intention in Adolescent Athletes: the Mediating Role of Moral Disengagement and Sportspersonship

Perfectionism and doping willingness in athletes: The mediating role of moral disengagement

Development of Experimental Materials on Moral Judgment in Sport: Evidence from Chinese Athletes

Attitudes of Sport Fans Toward the Electronic Sign-Stealing Scandal in Major League Baseball: Differing Associations With Perfectionism and Excellencism

Investigation of athlete high school students' moral decision-making attitudes in terms of sport variables

The Effects of Moral Self-Regulation on Prosocial Behavior and Rule Infraction

Decisional trade-offs towards doping and their association with moral attitudes and health risk perceptions: A mixed methods study

The meta-cognitive role of thought morality in attitude change and behavioural intentions related to doping

Moral competence, dilemma discussion, and sports: unraveling the significance of framework, competitive level, and sporting experience

Relationships among moral and contesting variables and prosocial and antisocial behavior in sport

Too much at stake to uphold sport integrity? High-performance athletes’ involvement in match-fixing

Morality in sport: The coach's perspective

Factors Affect Self-Handicapping of Individual Sport Athletes

Psychosocial predictors of doping intentions and use in sport and exercise: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Guilt, Shame and Academic Misconduct

Student and Teacher Views on Cheating in High School: Perceptions, Evaluations, and Decisions