Abstract:Abstract Object Electroencephalography (EEG) signals suffer from a low signal-to-noise ratio and are very susceptible to muscular, ambient noise, and other artifacts. Many artifact removal algorithms have been proposed to address this problem. However, the evaluation of these algorithms is conventionally too indirect (e.g., black-box comparisons of brain-computer interface performance before and after removal) because it is unclear which part of the signal represents raw EEG and which is noise. This project objectively benchmarks popular artifact removal algorithms and evaluates the fundamental Independent Component Analysis (ICA) approach thanks to a unique dataset where EEG is recorded simultaneously with other physiological signals-facial electromyography (EMG), accelerometers, and gyroscope-while ten subjects perform several repetitions of common artifact-inflicting tasks (blinking, speaking, etc.). Approach I have compared the correlation between EEG signals and the artifact-representing channels before and after applying an artifact removal algorithm across the different artifact-inflicting tasks. The extent to which an artifact removal method can reduce this correlation objectively quantifies its effectiveness for the different artifacts. In the same direction, I have determined to what extent ICA successfully detects artefactual components in EEG by comparing the corresponding correlations for independent components that are labelled as artifacts with those labeled as EEG. Main result The FORCe was found to be the most effective and generic artifact removal method, cleaning almost 40% of artifacts. ICA is shown to be able to isolate almost 70% of artefactual components. Significance This work alleviates the problem of unreliable evaluation of EEG artifact removal frameworks and provides the first reliable benchmark for the most popular algorithms in this literature.

An outlier detection-based method for artifact removal of few-channel EEGs

Eye Blink Artifact Detection Based on Multi-Dimensional EEG Feature Fusion and Optimization.

Eye Blink Artifact Detection with Novel Optimized Multi-Dimensional Electroencephalogram Features

An outlier detection based two-stage EEG artifact removal method using empirical wavelet transform and canonical correlation analysis

Efficient Rejection of Artifacts for Short-Term Few-Channel EEG Based on Fast Adaptive Multidimensional Sub-Bands Blind Source Separation

An Artefact Removal Method for EEG Without Reference Channel

Automatic Removal of Multiple Artifacts for Single-Channel Electroencephalography

State-of-the-art EEG artifact removal evaluation

[Research on automatic removal of ocular artifacts from single channel electroencephalogram signals based on wavelet transform and ensemble empirical mode decomposition]

Removal of Ocular and Muscular Artifacts from Multi-channel EEG Using Improved Spatial-Frequency Filtering

Remove Diverse Artifacts Simultaneously From a Single-Channel EEG Based on SSA and ICA: A Semi-Simulated Study.

[Methods for Processing Physiological Artifacts in Single/Few-Channel EEG Signals]

Automatic Artifact Removal from EEG - a Mixed Approach Based on Double Blind Source Separation and Support Vector Machine

Artifacts Removing Techniques on EEG Waveforms

Artifacts Reduction Method in EEG Signals with Wavelet Transform and Adaptive Filter.

A Preliminary Study of Muscular Artifact Cancellation in Single-Channel EEG

EEG artifact removal using sub-space decomposition, nonlinear dynamics, stationary wavelet transform and machine learning algorithms

Prior Artifact Information Based Automatic Artifact Removal from EEG Data

A Novel Method Based on Combination of Independent Component Analysis and Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition for Removing Electrooculogram Artifacts From Multichannel Electroencephalogram Signals

An Ocular Artifacts Removal Method Based on Canonical Correlation Analysis and Two-channel EEG Recordings

A Method of Removing Ocular Artifacts from EEG Using Discrete Wavelet Transform and Kalman Filtering.